Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search

The Tenth Walker  by Lindelea 699 Review(s)
Anso the HobbitReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/20/2005
Of course Bill understands! :) I like this! Sam is a bit like a pony, isn`t he? Sturdy and trustworthy and working hard without complaining. No wonder the pony feels a bit of kinship with him. :)

Author Reply: Oh, I'm glad you like it! Yes, I do think Sam is a bit like a pony, and he and Bill certainly strike up a friendship, from what I see in the book.


LarnerReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/17/2005
Ah, very good tale from Bill's point of view. Happy, groomed, cared for for a time, with two at least who seek to give him as much as they can, considering the circumstances.

And the fellow-feeling with Sam, and the identification with him as a possible fellow pony is wonderful.

Author Reply: Ah, thank you. Bill is sort of an offshoot of a joke of sorts, from a couple of years back, when I was tormenting Jodancingtree by writing snippets of a story in reviews of one of her stories, life as seen through the eyes of Pippin's pony Socks.

That one never got published, but a second series of story snippets, while I was reviewing another of her stories, became "Going, Going, Gone".

Yup, Sam is a wonder. Practically equine sometimes, that lad.

InklingReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/17/2005
Another one!? Your muse is really on a roll, Lin! As I've said before, you write faster than I read. Well, I will try to keep up with this one too as I have a soft spot for ponies...

The title makes me chuckle...this is a "Tenth Walker" story of a different color...sort of a "Pony Sue," you might say.

Author Reply: My Muse hates to finish things, and coming to the end of a story drives her to distraction. (Have nearly finished "Healer's Tale", and we are also working steadily towards the end of the re-creation of "Thain".)

Thus it is a distraction to give voice to a new story. It freshens things somehow and makes it less distressing to be coming to an end somewhere else.

Bless you for trying to keep up! (Used to be worse. When I had pneumonia and couldn't sleep, I was posting a couple of chapters a day.)

And thanks!

esamenReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/16/2005
Awww! So sweet! I think this must be my favorite of all the "Bill" stories.

I was hoping that the Master would make his appearance. Weary, but noble as always. . . that's my blue-eyed hero. And Sam is beautifully done. A lovely story. The only thing I didn't like was that it was too short.

I just love your work, Lindelea. Please write more! I'm always looking for your name at the top of the list.


Author Reply: Why, thank you! "Please write more", words to warm the cockles of an author's heart (whatever those are, *g*).

I'll do my best.

DreamflowerReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/16/2005
Good old Bill! I'm glad he's made a pest of himself to you--this promises to be fun!

I look forward to seeing his ponyish opinions on Merry and Pippin, on Asfaloth, on Rivendell...and then of course the Quest as far as Moria...wonder what he thought of Gandalf?

*chuckle* He's one opinionated pony!

Author Reply: Chuckling with you. I have never known a pony that wasn't opinionated. Full of personality (for good or ill) and some can be quite stubborn.

BodkinReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/16/2005
Good for Bill. He knows quality where he sees it - and he sees it in Sam. And he will give respect where Sam sees that it's due.

Author Reply: He's very bright, for a pony. And he is forming a high opinion of Sam, who, to his view, is practically pony himself. (High praise, coming from Bill.)

FantasyFanReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/15/2005
Maybe done before, but I'm sure you'll put your unique stamp on this. What I like already is that one chapter in, Bill loves Frodo and trusts Sam. With a beginning like that, he deserves to be called the Tenth Walker.

Author Reply: Thank you! I felt the need of some "easy" writing, with little research beyond reading the original work, which I've started over anyhow. It is fun to imagine what goes on inside the head of a pony like Bill, who I recall Samwise said was practically human, or something to that effect. Haven't quite got that far in my re-reading yet!

Comments, of course, are welcome, even for the lighter fare.


harrowcatReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/15/2005
What a lovely start. Please keep on giving Bill your sugar so that we get to hear more!

Author Reply: I can see my sugar bill is about to skyrocket.


Loremaster of AnorienReviewed Chapter: Prologue on 6/15/2005
I like it! Poor Bill, I would dislike Men, too, if I was treated like that.
Keep writing!


Author Reply: Poor Bill, indeed, but things are looking up. Sort of. (At least he has a nice long stretch in Rivendell to look forward to.)


First Page | Previous Page | Next Page | Last Page

Return to Chapter List