|About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search|
|A Lesson on Hobbits by Budgielover||16 Review(s)|
|Celeste Lucretia Black||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 5/12/2021|
|This made me laugh a little. Pippin is the youngest brother, innocent and naive but just as loyal and protective. Merry is the middle brother, intelligent and mischievous and Frodo the eldest.|
|docmon||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 5/7/2008|
|terrific! love the comparison of hobbits to cats! Never realized how alike they were.|
|Pearl Took||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 3/20/2008|
|I do love Gimli! Gimli and hobbits is even better. I'm sure he would be wonderfully warm and toasty.|
I'm sure their trustfulness would be a surprise, though I'm sure he wouldn't find it so much so in the Shire! LOL
Well done, Budgie!
|Hai Took||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 1/24/2005|
|Thank you for this story! You wrote Gimli so well in his feeling a bit awkward with the hobbits and then accepting it and feeling protective of them. I am always rather amazed that in the books (and movies) it is Gimli who is insistant on knowing where Merry and Pippin are after they have been captured and Gandalf is trying to get them to go to Edoras. Thank you for the wonderful hobbit/Gimli moment!|
Author Reply: It is so true that Gimli is often the one to watch over the hobbits, isn't it? I would love to seen more of him in canon, and more of the relationship between our lads and the Big People. Ah well, that's what fanfiction is for, isn't it?
|Larner||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 1/23/2005|
|Very beautiful images, and lovely writing and characterization. Love it.|
Author Reply: I'm so glad you enjoyed it. I have given quite a bit of thought to how the Big People of the Fellowship must have reacted to hobbits. None but Gandalf and Aragorn had much interaction with hobbit-kind, and Aragorn only as an observer. Don't you get the feeling that the hobbits must have enjoyed befuddling the Big Folk?
|Pearl Took||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 1/23/2005|
|How does the lover of wee birds know one of the most important rules of being owned by cats? The person whose lap the cat has chosen is forgiven any duties that involve moving the cat. :) :) It is a wonderful excuse that I have often used myself to get out of doing things! LOL|
This is a charming and "warm" story, a joy to read as always. Thank you for a wonderful tale!
Author Reply: I love my birdies but also cats (and dogs and horses and aquarium fish and guinea pigs and rabbits and skunks and horny toads and just about everything, unfortunately) and know that the cat's comfort comes first, if you are honored enough to be chosen as lap-warmer. Somehow I see the hobbits quite unintentionally molding the Big People to their needs, like cats. And we feel so special to have the privilege of catering to them. I'm so glad you enjoyed the story!
|Mysterious Jedi||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 1/23/2005|
|Excellent little stories!|
Author Reply: *giggle* And a joy to write. There is so much to explore yet in the relationships between the Big People and the hobbits. Wouldn't it be fun to turn the series around, and have each of the Big People teach the hobbits something about themselves? I'll have to think about that...
|elliska||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 1/23/2005|
|"I do not know if it is a strength or a weakness to be so trusting." |
That is one of my favorite themes in LotR and you have captured it wonderfully here. I must say that you said you would make a hobbit lover out of me and you are indeed doing that Budgielover. Your stories are excellent. I love the way you paint the hobbits' personalities.
the young one’s ability to leap from subject to subject like a butterfly in a flower-field,
What a lovely description. Great story!
Author Reply: Hullo, Elliska! Thank you for your kind words. You hit on one of the things in LotRs that never ceases to amaze me; the complexity and richness of Tolkien's universe. So many themes, so beautifully presented. And welcome to the world of hobbit-lovers! Hobbits may be less heroic than Men and less lovely than Elves, but we are a happy, social bunch. Pour yourself a half-pint and settle in!
|GamgeeFest||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 1/23/2005|
|Hobbits as cats - what a perfect comparison really. And what a comfy, cozy picture that paints against the bone-chilling cold. Merry and Pippin will be the warmest of the company that night. And good ole Sam, keeping the water warm for tea. A lovely story!|
Author Reply: Somehow the image of Gimli sitting there, carefully not moving so he doesn't disturb the hobbits, reminds me of a mother cat with kittens. Poor Gimli doesn't quite know how he got into that position, but he's enjoying it. So do the hobbits, quite innocently and unexpectedly, enchant us all...
|meckinock||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 1/23/2005|
|I loved the comparison of hobbits to cats; and how delightful that they chose Gimli as their sleeping cushion. The interactions of all the characters were very comfortable and enjoyable, and the little details like Aragorn balancing on Gimli's shoulder to stand added to the sense of place and feeling of camaraderie. |
Author Reply: I think of this type of story as "Forging of the Friendship" stories, the backstories that Professor Tolkien inferred but didn't have room for in canon. Who could resist the hobbits? Not Gimli, not Aragorn, and certainly, none of us...