Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search
swiss replica watches replica watches uk Replica Rolex DateJust Watches

If You Could See What I Hear  by cathleen 5 Review(s)
Pearl TookReviewed Chapter: 6 on 1/27/2008
Most curious! Paladin didn't actually find Tulip . . . did he? Pip is in the woods . . . isn't he?

I really sympathize with Merry and all the family that is with him. They are so frightened.

Looking forward to more :-)

Author Reply: Thanks so much, Pearl! Yes, they're frightened, but at the same time, I think they all know how adventuresome Pip is. I like to imagine that some among them 'know' for certain that he will be found safe and sound.

Hmm, *did* Pad find Tulip???

GoldenReviewed Chapter: 6 on 1/26/2008
Another great Chapter! :D I loved this from beginning to end and how your decribe this small earth fairy is wonderful.
I think when Pip is grown, like maybe after the Quest and not as "innocent" as before with all the evil he has seen, how would it be, when he and Roswhen meet again?

Author Reply: Thanks, hon! And - oh my! I see those dangerous wheels are turning in your head....Pip and Rhoswen meet again later? Well, we'll see. It's certainly not out of the realm of possibility.....

AndreaReviewed Chapter: 6 on 1/25/2008
Wow! I just discovered this story today and I read it in one go!

Roshwen seems to be a lot like Pippin! Alfie, who might be a leader of her kind, reacts differently. And I would trust her to bring Pippin back to his own world. For he left his world when he brushed the primroses against that huge stone, right?

I agree with Pippin that Tulip sounds a lot like his mother! But that's exactly what he needs at times ;-)

Paladin is on the right track, and I loved it to see that his "Sight" reassured him that his son was in no danger.

I only wonder what Saradoc and his companions will find! They follow the wrong direction, don't they?

Well, we'll see ...

Thank you for another wonderful story :)

Author Reply: Hmm, I'm thinking that we won't know which direction is 'right' or 'wrong' - I think all roads will eventually lead to Pippin!

Thank you so very much for your generous comments!!

LarnerReviewed Chapter: 6 on 1/25/2008
At least Merry is thinking on what Pippin might have done; and with the practicality of Hobbits Eglantine is planning for all contingencies.

Love the search as being followed by Pal, and his trust in his Sight. Now, to find Tulip like that.... Is Pippin in the throes of his own vision granted by the sight? Now I'm wondering just where Pippin WILL be found!

And I love the look at all the small guardians Pippin is meeting. Perhaps he will find it that much the easier in the distant future when he sees Frodo leave Middle Earth, knowing that so many will be watching over his beloved older cousin.

Author Reply: Ah, but has Pad actually found Tulip?

As always, thank you so much for following my little tale and giving me your FB - muchly appreciated, Larner!

shireboundReviewed Chapter: 6 on 1/25/2008
My goodness, I hope someone believes Pippin's story when he tells it. What an unusual adventure for him and Tulip.

Author Reply: Yes, it's certainly not an ordinary day, huh? Thanks for your comments Shirebound, they are much appreciated, as always!

Return to Chapter List