Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search
swiss replica watches replica watches uk Replica Rolex DateJust Watches

The Queen's Orc  by jodancingtree 6 Review(s)
obsidianjReviewed Chapter: 35 on 10/17/2004
This is such a delightful story. I started with Following the Other Wizard and fell in love with Canohando. When I saw there is a sequel I started reading it. I like the way you describe the last days of Aragorn and Arwen through the very unique point of view of an Orc. When Aragorn went to his last rest I had tears in my eyes.

I love it that Canohando is still an Orc. He has to fight the habits of a lifetime but he can do it. The deep rooted hatred between the different races is not easily overcome. It takes a wizard to smooth the waters.

Thank you for writing this story. I hope to see the next chapter soon.


Author Reply: Oh Chris, thank you! I've gotten to love that Orc so much myself, it just delights me when someone else loves him too!

And as much as he wants to be something different, he is still, always, an Orc...


esamenReviewed Chapter: 35 on 10/9/2004
But the Hobbit turned so sharply that the water in his pail sloshed out over his feet.

"Canohando?" he repeated. His eyes were round with wonder. "Canohando the Orc?"

Oh, cruel, cruel jodancingtree! Evil cliffhanger! how on earth do you expect me to work, or cook, or write my own stories, when you leave me staring at the screen like this!

Let's see. It can't be one of the four Travellers, since they have seen orcs and elves. Is it one of Sam's children? But this meeting is happening on the east side of the Shire, I think? Not in the Westmarch?

You are so mean. Please update quickly or I will have to come over there! Will bribes of chocolate and champagne hurry you along? I'll send some right away.


daw the minstrelReviewed Chapter: 35 on 10/9/2004
Oh how exciting! They're finally nearing the Shire. And Canohando's name is known there.

Radagast is kind but not stupid, and I'm glad he's trying to talk some sense in to Malawen.

Author Reply: Yes, I would think Radagast would be appalled that Canohando might give up Valinor, because of Malawen's self-centeredness. But whether even the Brown Wizard can get through to the Elf-girl...

But I must say, I didn't expect quite so many hobbits! I asked for one, and along comes a whole gaggle of them - they're far too chummy, is what it is!
Wondering what to do with them all,


Breon BriarwoodReviewed Chapter: 35 on 10/9/2004
Ah! I had nearly forgot that Frodo went home after his travels. Of course Canohando's name is known in the Shire. Maybe the hobbit's acceptance of Malawen will ease her thoughts regarding Valinor?

Author Reply: And Frodo being Frodo, he must have written something about Canohando, don't you think? A brief memoir of his travels with Radagast, and the Orcs' healing?


Gentle HobbitReviewed Chapter: 35 on 10/8/2004
Ah! Hobbits know of Canohando! Frodo's story of his brother has reached beyond Sam, Merry or Pippin. I am looking forward eagerly to seeing how this unfolds. And I also am hoping so much for Malawen to thaw and allow Canohando to be "not torn in two". I so want him to be able to sail. I have not felt this attached to an original character before, and it is your skillful writing that has made me so.

Author Reply: You wrote: "I have not felt this attached to an original character before..."

Thank you, Gentle Hobbit! I've gotten to really love this Orc, and I'm so glad that you've gotten attached to him. And I'm still feeling my way, to know how it will all turn out.


Rose SaredReviewed Chapter: 35 on 10/8/2004
Oh, horay, for once good words proceed Canohardo instead of ill will - great.
Lovely chapter - I so liked stern Radagast.
well done

Author Reply: Oh, good! I was afraid he would not be believable - I'm glad he was!


Return to Chapter List