Reviews (90)

Andrea · 19 August 2017 · Chapter 27: Tricks and Duels

When it came time to awaken, he would simply refuse to do so. And that's what he did, the stubborn Baggins. But the combined power of Gandalf and Elrond was apparently too much for him. Now I hope, Pippin's plans to cheer him up will work out.

Larner · 9 August 2017 · Chapter 27: Tricks and Duels

Poor Frodo--it does seem too much to have to drain the wound for a fourth time! No wonder he doesn't want to awaken. But Gandalf knows how to awaken him, I see. Yes, Hobbits can certainly be stubborn, and this Baggins is often the most stubborn of the lot!

Larner · 23 July 2016 · Chapter 26: Discovered

Now, this is quite the sacrifice to contemplate, much less carry through on! But it will hopefully be worth it for both of them!

shirebound · 23 July 2016 · Chapter 26: Discovered

Elrond is so wise... and so sneaky! What a marvelous suggestion, to have Aragorn 'test' the curative which will help him, as well. I believe the Ring and Frodo are engaged in a great war of wills with one another and it is this that has robbed him of any progress he should have made in his recuperation. Poor Frodo. What an exhausting, courageous battle.

spinster · 4 July 2016 · Chapter 3: A Team Effort

I am just into chapter 2 and enjoying it immensely. I do enjoy elvish medicinal treatments too. It lends such depth and authenticity to the story. HOWEVER, if you are not going to research the herbs you reference, at least offer a prominent disclaimer the this is just for fun and not to be taken as genuine herbal advice. The case in point here is Arnica, which, according to a number of sources that I have, has never been known to have antibiotic properties. If I am mistaken and you do have a resource that references antibiotic properties for Arnica, I beg your pardon. I would be interested in adding that source to my library. Please e-mail me. I am returning now to your excellent story. Thank you

Andrea · 12 June 2016 · Chapter 25: A Moment of Bliss

Wonderful! Sometimes a simple bath is all that is needed - at least for Aragorn and Frodo. But why was Sam so angry? Because of what Frodo said to Elrond, or is it something else?

Larner · 6 June 2016 · Chapter 25: A Moment of Bliss

Oh, dear--get him nicely clean, warm, and relaxed, and then have a confrontation with a decidedly angry Sam Gamgee! At least Aragorn is being amused. Heh!

shirebound · 6 June 2016 · Chapter 25: A Moment of Bliss

Pip, if you didn’t do the things you do you wouldn’t be my Pip. You’d be boring like Merry Love it. Such a delightful chapter, with baths and hair washings and sweet hobbity care.

Andrea · 22 November 2015 · Chapter 24: Hard Work and Heartache

Frodo can be VERY stubborn at times! And now I am very interested to find out how the others persuaded him to accompany him much further than the borders of Imladris.

Larner · 17 November 2015 · Chapter 24: Hard Work and Heartache

Accepting that he cannot do it alone and that no one can take the blame for their current circumstances save for the Ring Itself is not an easy thing for Frodo to do, of course. Hopefully a good sleep will help him recover faster.

Lindelea · 23 April 2014 · Chapter 23: Small Steps

I do like the idea of Aragorn being an honorary hobbit! Yikes! Poor Frodo! (Thinking he's a jinx and all)

Andrea · 23 April 2014 · Chapter 23: Small Steps

It's the same situation all over again, only with swapped roles. But this time Gandalf is there to prevent Aragorn from doing something stupid ;-) I am not so sure, though, if Aragorn could have mustered the strength to reach Frodo's bedside on his own. But he would have tried nevertheless! “Of course, Aragorn, but Merry and Pippin have also volunteered to help in your physical therapy,” the wizard said with a chuckle. That should be indeed interesting!

Larner · 23 April 2014 · Chapter 23: Small Steps

Well, Aragorn at least is recovering at last! The infection is clearing up, and he's able at last to take an interest in what's going on around him. And he's as guilty as Frodo of putting others' needs before his own, I suspect.

Andrea · 16 February 2014 · Chapter 22: The Herald of Gil-Galad

Oh my! I agree with the others: Hearon will NEVER forget to wash his hands again! And I hope Pippin will be in time to clean the seats...

Anonymous · 15 February 2014 · Chapter 22: The Herald of Gil-Galad

Really enjoyed this hope there will be more

Dreamflower · 27 January 2014 · Chapter 22: The Herald of Gil-Galad

Uh-oh. Pippin! I love Elrond going into "herald mode". And I cringed when Hearon said "at least it wasn't an important step"!

Larner · 27 January 2014 · Chapter 22: The Herald of Gil-Galad

They now know WHY he was made Gil-galad's herald, don't they? Heh! And they have managed to avert an even worse infection. As for the apprentice--he will NEVER forget to wash his hands again, I suspect! (And I do hope that those privies are clean when Elves come to use them!)

Dreamflower · 3 October 2013 · Chapter 21: Forays of Foolishness

Oh dear! Poor Frodo! Poor Aragorn! That's one determined Baggins!

Larner · 1 October 2013 · Chapter 21: Forays of Foolishness

At least they can now drain it, now that the infection is obviously draining. Bless Frodo for wishing to help his beloved friend as he could.

Andrea · 29 September 2013 · Chapter 21: Forays of Foolishness

That proves that the transitions between stubbornness and foolishness are smooth! Now Frodo has to wait yet again for his long-desired bath. But who knows how long it would have taken Elrond to find the cause of Aragorn's lasting fever otherwise?

obsidianj · 13 July 2013 · Chapter 20: Tender Care

Oh, to be in the care of hobbits when you are sick. Although, I could do without the pain...

Andrea · 20 April 2013 · Chapter 20: Tender Care

Pippin blushed, “Frodo, I was only trying to say…” “I think you have said enough, Pip,” Merry glared at him. LOL!!! Poor Pippin! He is always trying so hard to please everyone. But it was funny ;-) To be in the care of hobbits is the best that someone could wish for!

Larner · 16 April 2013 · Chapter 20: Tender Care

These two are truly having more than their share of pain, although they are getting a good deal of comforting from the rest. And I'd LOVE to have the Hobbits and Aragorn taking care of me should I be so injured and ill! Heh!

estelnalissi · 6 April 2013 · Chapter 1: Never Underestimate a Hobbit

Reading Chapter one of The Honorary Hobbit made a great day even better. I love nothing better than to read hobbitcentric stories and this chapter abounds with examples of their irresistable charm. Even in a weakened state, your Frodo shows his inner metal, but you didn't neglect that vulnerability that inspires others to care for him. I feel The impetous for this story hinges upon Frodo's comment that he felt like a caged animal only to be released when it was time for him to carry the ring to Mordor. His dread escalated during the time he isolated himself in the sick room. He needed to put some positive, diverting experience between himself and his fear. You made the point so clearly that first he had to eat to fuel his recovery after which he could reconnect with his friends and experience the beauty and delight of the Last Homely House. You have such a humorous, upbeat touch while being mindful that beneath the amusing spats, Frodo's heart and will are strong. I so enjoyed the bartering scene and the little touch that though Frodo attempted to eat exactly half of his meal, he couldn't resist those fresh raspberries. "Take them ... anywhere," certainly summed up Elrond's delimma with hobbits with too much time on their hands. Sam's short appearance and the mention of Merry and Pippin, as well as curiosity to see more of Rivendell highten my anticipation to continue this story. However, I'm enjoying it so much that I'll be pacing myself knowing I'll reach the end all too soon.

obsidianj · 17 March 2013 · Chapter 19: Stubborn and Stubboner

I can so understand Aragorn. It is appalling when you are not able to feed yourself. At least he seems to admit finally that he is sick and needs some help.