Reviews (50)

Queen Galadriel · 2 January 2007 · Chapter 18: The End

Oh, I forgot I hadn't finished this! I was missing a lot! All these are sooooo sweeeeeet!!! :) Poor Sam, to fall out of a tree! No wonder he'd never want to climb a tree again! That was always my fear when I was little and my brother dared me to climb to such and such a branch, in these little skinny sapling things! So funny to hear Bilbo described as bouncy. LOL! I guess he is, in some ways. And I love the little friendly argument as to whether Sam can be compared to Bilbo as far as "nice-ness" (not a word, I know) goes. Love the indoor adventures :), and that Ted does have a lot of nerve, mean thing. *gives him the glare* Unfortunately we learn later that Ted and Lotho made a very horribly effective team; where Lotho led, Ted followed. I can't bring myself to pity them. Love the vocab lessons! Reminds me of what my grandma did for me when I was little. I used to be southern to the extreme LOL, and every time I went to her house she'd sit me down, give me something fun to do, and while I did it, she taught me new words and proper grammar and vocabulary. :) I can really sympathize (empathize?) with Sam here. I love fussing over my dear ones, but when I get fussed over...I *hate* it! It's so *embarrassing*! Also love the bit about Sam not wanting to leave the Shire unless he was with Frodo, and Frodo saying what adventures they had. They had no idea they really would, and it would be more than they could have imagined then. And dear Sam, finally admitting how much he needs his Frodo. And Frodo must have been so torn, though he'd never tell either Sam or Merry so. So sweet of Merry to realise that it was important that Frodo be with Sam as well and let him go. And the end was absolutely priceless! Tell Eleon I said she did a perfectly marvelous job and brought tears to my eyes with it. Again, you two did super, and this looks like it was tremendous fun. Now I want to do something like this...I think I might have to coax FB a lot first though, and maybe that's not such a good idea right now? :) God bless, Galadriel :)

Larner · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 18: The End

How right!

Larner · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 17: Frodo

Oh, wonderful for Sam, that Merry, too, sees the need for Frodo to spend time with Sam as well as himself.

Larner · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 16: Sam

Yes, only for Frodo would he leave home and the Shire, but he would indeed come home again. And Lotho and Ted DID scheme up a storm, didn't they? Glad he is able to wish the right wish in spite of his own desires.

harrowcat · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 18: The End

Awww! *sniff, sniff*

harrowcat · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 17: Frodo

Frodo must be feling very torn - both his friends need him and he can't split himself in two. Well done Merry!

harrowcat · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 16: Sam

Oh poor Sam - trying so very hard not to be selfish and jellous but it comes out at last.

harrowcat · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 15: Frodo

Trust Frodo to hold out hope to Sam. Poor Merry I hope the fever abates soon. True, those two nasty people could either hurt each other or band together to be even worse.

harrowcat · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 14: Sam

Oh Sam! So modest yet wise, so perceptive but still able to be feeling a little lonely.

harrowcat · 6 November 2006 · Chapter 13: Frodo

I love the indoor adventures. Hobbit youngsters are always able to make the best of a bad situation.

Frodo Baggins · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 2: Sam

AWW! I just want to hug little Sam! He's so adorable! Tell Eleon she did an adorable job with him! *hugs him and hurries off to reply* *oops, not me* LOL! God Bless, Frodo Baggins

Frodo Baggins · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 1: Frodo

Aww! I can't believe I haven't been reading this. Very good, so far! Namarie! Yours, Frodo B

Antane · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 18: The End

I forgot to mention - you can't have it end here! Do another one with them taking care of each other, reading that book etc. :) And that was nice of Sam to say he hoped Merry would get better and for Merry to realize that Frodo should go back.

Antane · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 18: The End

Oh, Sam, how could you ever doubt? But it's good to have that bond affirmed. Remember this, you two - nothing can sever it no matter what distance physically separates you, your hearts will ever be united. Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Antane · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 17: Frodo

Which is probably why I need you the most. You keep me out of trouble. I do believe that the reason Iluvatar created Sam was to love Frodo. This is just wonderful that they both know how dependent and needed they are to each other, as if there was any doubt but cute that they write so to each other. Lovely! Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Antane · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 16: Sam

I love this whole letter! Sam admiting he's going to be selfish (as if he has a selfish bone in his body, dear me), saying how much he needs Frodo and how he would never leave the Shire unless it was with him and that Frodo would make sure he enjoyed himself. Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

shirebound · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 18: The End

Sam waited to read the elvish story until Frodo came home. He couldn't possibly read it himself anyway, with all those tears of joy, contentedness, and overwhelming love blocking his sight. "Sam! Mister Frodo's back!" Yay! This leaves me with such a happy feeling.

shirebound · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 17: Frodo

I just love that phrase "my Sam".

shirebound · 5 November 2006 · Chapter 16: Sam

I don't think I could leave the Shire, ever. Unles...unless I was with you. Awww! And Sam's writing skill is getting so much better!

Antane · 4 November 2006 · Chapter 15: Frodo

Good that Merry and Frodo had some adventures and that he'll soon be back with his other brother. Poor Merry though. Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Antane · 4 November 2006 · Chapter 13: Frodo

So nice to see another batch of letters! I love that Frodo is enjoying translating his tale because of who he is doing it for, saying he is missing Sam and having fun being sick with Merry. I remember my sister and I being sick once and we were competing for who could have a higher fever (not that we were encouraging it of course, it just happened) and it's always good to use that opportunity to catch up on reading! Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

harrowcat · 4 November 2006 · Chapter 13: Frodo

I am glad that Sam does get to learn some elvish. I would love to learn it too but RL gets in the way as well as reading these many wonderful stories. I will just have to get by with the little I learn from them. And Ted is really, really nasty!

Larner · 3 November 2006 · Chapter 15: Frodo

Nah, I'm with Sam--leave them with no other company than their own, and let them suffer so no one else has to. I'll admit I tend to get vindictive with such folk, but want them to punish themselves. Heh! And let's have the animals fight a nice, scary dragon that they conquer with ease! Yes!

Larner · 3 November 2006 · Chapter 14: Sam

I've often wished to lock folk I find tiresome up together--such as the hackers who've sent the viruses that have clogged up my computer's memory. I HATE hackers, you know. And hope that Sam gets to hear that story soon.

Larner · 3 November 2006 · Chapter 13: Frodo

Ah, Ted isn't a very nice Hobbit, is he? And I'd be wary of any get-well message that might originate with him. Love the little "inside" adventures they must experience as Frodo and Merry can't go out right now.