Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search

From Wilderness to Cities White  by Larner 391 Review(s)
PERIANTARIReviewed Chapter: 46 on 4/10/2023
What an interesting scene- first Denethor of despair but Faramir to hope and it's great foreshadowing that you would want the land to be planted with greenery again which is what Faramir eventually did with Eowyn. :)

Author Reply: Oh, yes--Faramir and Eowyn must have rejoiced to see their new home again filled with natural beauty as it hadn't seen for decades.

Denethor was wrong this time, wasn't he? Heh!

Thanks so for reading back into this collection.

periantariReviewed Chapter: 69 on 4/10/2023
wow what a scene to write about- it's always so emotional to think of what the hobbits have gone through and what it took Aragorn to bring them back from the brink of death. :*(

Author Reply: I know. That the Master wrote that Frodo awoke under trees always has intrigued me.

shireboundReviewed Chapter: 69 on 4/10/2023
a sky of clear blue such as had not been seen in this region of Gondor for most of his lifetime.

What a nice detail. And ohhh, what a gentle, peaceful, and loving scene. *happy sigh*

An early Happy Birthday to you, my friend! :)

Author Reply: How dark Ithilien must have been so much of the time. I'm certain that a clear sky so close to the walls of Mordor must have been a distinct relief to so many people.

Thanks, and I hope you enjoy my birthday mathom that's been posted today. Bless you!

LindeleaReviewed Chapter: 68 on 2/25/2021
Hahahaha! Perfect ending. Reminds me of my mom wanting to name the new puppy (when I was 5) "Mittens" - he had enormous feet... Nubbin sounds like a cousin to the pup Pippin "owns" in Gondor for a time in some of my stories, who was loosely based on a large, shaggy pup (of a Giant breed) you used to know (though the personality fits more with the current shaggy pup, come to think of it).

So many lovely touches! Sam, the "willing slave". "Right things to chew on" - ah, very wise. And somehow a hobbity proverb popped into mind: "As useless as an old boot outside o' Buckland!" Charcoal reminds me of a Blue Heeler we once owned, quite the enforcer. Recently, the (now-grown) wee hobbits told me he used to herd them to bed, nipping at their heels, when he thought it was high time for bedtime. Nor did he suffer fools (or foolishness) gladly. He was a stickler for under-control behavior.

Sneezles around dogs! Excellent solution for Frodo not growing up with a canine best friend. Maybe they wouldn't have known that terriers are more likely to be hypoallergenic, like our last two furry family members. (Ah, but I miss Alsatian intelligence and sensitivity and Labrador playfulness and wit...)

Sam holding the pup out at arm's length - very natural and real. And of course Farmer Cotton would have recognized the signs...

Best to you and your furry contingent, and thanks for the smile today.

Author Reply: Mittens would most likely have surprised her as Nubbin is likely to surprise Sam! How wonderful! Am not certain what breed Nubbin is, but is likely to be a herding breed if he came from the Green Hills region. I imagine him to be very furry, after all.

Oh, but I love that proverb! How apropos! Perfect! Your blue heeler sounds indeed like Charcoal as I've imagined her. Our Prissy, the basis of my mom's kennel, had her own distinct ideas on child raising, and was constantly shaking her head as to our lack of discipline.

I enjoyed writing this one so, and am so glad you appreciate it. As for your beloved former furry companion--how well I remember her and her "baby" seal. I was pleased that when Tilion's black and silver sister was adopted, her new family unwittingly made her your beloved's namesake! She has her momma's facial structure, and her daddy's tendency to make certain other creatures' faces, ears, noses, and eyes are kept clean.

Love to all.

PeriantariReviewed Chapter: 65 on 2/24/2021
Lovely characterizations and wonderful insightful gap-filler. Leaves me to think about more about the power of the Ring and the essence of what it means to offer it and not to take it.

Author Reply: Oh, I am so glad you appreciate this story. We know that Galadriel was willing to diminish her own power rather than to accept the Ring, but it still must have startled her when Frodo did offer it.

Thanks so very much!

PeriantariReviewed Chapter: 68 on 2/24/2021
It seems like Frodo would be a dog person. I really liked how you wrote Tom in this-- really sounds like Tom Cotton... the accent and all. Good to see you writing again. :)

Author Reply: Oh, I am so glad you feel I have caught Tom's voice. How much he must have enjoyed his daughter's husband's rare signs of naivete! Had Frodo been brought up with dogs close about I suspect he might have turned out a dog person; but the signs are that he wasn't, so I had to think up plausible reasons why he might have been terrified for so long by Maggot's dogs. Heh!

As for the lack of writing--the last four years were traumatic, particularly since I have always been devoted to the good of others. To see lies, greed, and self-absorption corrupting the White House and its primary supporters has been traumatic and disheartening. I am so glad that our current administration is the polar opposite to its predecessor!

PeriantariReviewed Chapter: 16 on 2/24/2021
Very clever. Really made me smile at the end. Very nice.

Author Reply: I love thia one, too. Pippin is now indeed the wise fool!

shireboundReviewed Chapter: 68 on 2/24/2021
*huge grin* You know how much I love the idea of dogs at Bag End! What a delight for the family this one will be, and what a surprise when it starts to grow... and grow. This is a lucky pup to have found such a warm home; he'll certainly be well fed! I enjoyed this very much.

Author Reply: Oh, yes--any animal under Sam's care will never want for food! And after the last story I posted, I had to do this one as a prequel.

KathyGReviewed Chapter: 68 on 2/23/2021
Hey, Larner, it appears that someone decided that your story collection would be a great place to sell shoes! =) Look at your story summary, and you'll find the link that the hacker posted.

With that said, it'll be interesting to see how that puppy fares at Bag End! Is it going to end up the size of a Great Dane? It could be bigger than a grown hobbit if it does! =)

Author Reply: I found I had to write a backstory for Nubbin as I depicted him in my last story, A Star's Light at Midnight. As one who's raised dogs, I love to imagine how people who don't know dogs learn such facts.

As for the hacking it's not the first time nor likely the last. Thanks so!

ibonekiReviewed Chapter: 65 on 6/4/2019
This is stunning. I somehow never read this chapter. How I cherish your insight into these characters, filling the gaps with such precision. I imagine this conversation to have truly happened, it feels so right.

Author Reply: I know this is terribly late, but somehow I missed this comment. Thank you so for it, and for appreciating what I write. It's taking me far longer to write things any more, part, I suppose, of being so much older now. Thank you so much!

First Page | Previous Page | Next Page | Last Page

Return to Chapter List