Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search

Rhyselle's Library  by Rhyselle 5 Review(s)
LarnerReviewed Chapter: 27 on 9/19/2010
Alas that he must find his healing so, rather than with those who knew Frodo in life. I think he would have loved Tol Eressea, and suspect that Frodo had hoped he would be able to rejoiced in such memories as they might have shared.

Lovely, but sad.

Lady EdlynReviewed Chapter: 27 on 9/13/2010
This made me cry. Not out of sorrow but because Ulmo's act was one of absolute and perfect mercy. The grief that would have encompassed SAm had he reached Tol Erresea to find Frodo had already passed on would have injured his fea so badly that it might never really heal.

If you haven't entered this in the MEFAs for this year it ought to be!

cookiefleckReviewed Chapter: 27 on 9/3/2010
I've re-read this several times and thought about the premise. I think it's more cruel of Ulmo to deprive Sam of his free will and make that decision for him. Sam is quite the stout-hearted fellow, as we know. And, after all, he might have wanted to see Tol Eressea before moving on to the next destination. Also, the implication that he drowned also conjures up images of fright and terror. Interesting premise... food for thought.

shireboundReviewed Chapter: 27 on 9/1/2010
It's lovely to think that the Ring-bearers would be treated with such tenderness and compassion.

CeleritasReviewed Chapter: 27 on 9/1/2010

I really, really love this spin--both on fanon itself and on the essay--(you've outlined a possibility that I at least had never thought of, and I already have two options--one that existed before the essay and one that sprung up afterwards in a commentfest).

This has just enough of the disturbing quality to it (what happened? If the ship sank, did any elves go down with it? Were Sam's last thoughts ones of despair or did he actually go down in his sleep?) to make Ulmo actually feel like a Vala and one that is perilous at that--despite the greater good and the comfort that we know was behind his intentions. And all in a hundred words! Well done!

Return to Chapter List