Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search

Out of All Knowledge  by Budgielover 131 Review(s)
Tiinaj1Reviewed Chapter: 15 on 9/27/2015
That was wonderfully written! I'm going to favorite this story & author. One of the things I felt you did here was explain why Elrond was hesitant about letting Pippin go on the journey. You could feel his immaturity.

hannahmReviewed Chapter: 10 on 8/6/2010
aww poor frodo - am loving this side of the story tho its great to hear of what happened in rivendell before he wakes up!

in 'recovery in rivendell' you say that frodo has prophetic dreams sometimes, is this happening here? his dream when he wakes up seems very similiar to when he's trapped in the tower of cirith ungol and he thinks the ring is gone!

and just to add your writing is amazing :)

LaurelinReviewed Chapter: 15 on 2/25/2009
Ok this was definitely your best so far!!! I loved it sooooooo much I'm trying to read them in order haha and so far nothing can equal this. It really covered a gap that tolkien left and i'm glad that someone had the sense to fill it in correctly :) so good jod it was great!

LaurelinReviewed Chapter: 10 on 2/25/2009
"What is it? What have you done to my boy?"
I love the way Bilbo talks about Frodo as if he really was his father its really sweet!

LaurelinReviewed Chapter: 2 on 2/25/2009
7 Oh My God!!! I love this story so far. Haha I was in the school library while reading this chapter, and when Merry and Bilbo were reunited I started crying& every body was staring at me and the librarian came over to ask me if i was ok! But anyway... I love this, its really good!

AlassielReviewed Chapter: 15 on 7/8/2004
Thank you for a wonderfully engaging tale. I have often thought about what those first days in Rivendell were like. I loved the detail--from the surgery to the food and found myself alternately shivering with apprehension and laughing out loud.

PeriantariReviewed Chapter: 9 on 5/14/2004
oh jeez... that just wow~ i have no words to describe my amazement
and then with everyone breaking down :*( :*( :*( i am so in tears with this story~!
poor hobbitses :*(
i like the concept of having the Ring at least preserve Frodo's life longer... very interesting to mention that...

PeriantariReviewed Chapter: 8 on 5/14/2004
This story is so angsty!!! ahhhh~!!! Frodo not breathing??? ahhh~!!! ::runs to last chapter::

but one quick note: I LOVE your hobbit interactions and i really like your Merry... he really seems to know what's happening and is just so perceptive. Your characters ring really true to me and the angst :*( oh man...the angst :*( :*( crycry.... wow...amazing~

PeriantariReviewed Chapter: 6 on 5/13/2004
I feel like one needs lots of guts to read this... i read through to this chapter the first time around and the angst surrounding this story through the hobbits' point of view was so much to me that I stopped... i'm so glad i started again for I appreciate it a lot... your characterizations for all characters especially Merry and Sam are wonderfully written and portrayed. The angst surrounding this has me in tears.
I really love your Sam and your Merry :*)
Wonderful story~ ::continuing to read and can't wait till Elrond removes the shard::

great job~

cuthalionReviewed Chapter: 15 on 4/30/2004
Ah - finally! Thank you for the last chapter - even for the hint of sadness at the end, when Merry dreams about going home, and everone knows that he will not go home for a very long time, and that there are frightening adventures to come in the future...You kept me on the hook all the time; you're very good writer, really. Thank you again!

First Page | Previous Page | Next Page | Last Page

Return to Chapter List