Sorry to spam you, but after looking over my "Faramir: film vs book" review, I would change "noble but despairing Man" to "noble but resigned Man" in the book. When he volunteers to defend the River crossing, he sounds more resigned than despairing – maybe a subtle nuance, but the distinction feels important to me in terms of sketching his character. "resigned" because he knows the odds. Moments before Denethor issues his challenge to the captains attending the Council meeting, Faramir himself sums up the situation, revealing his capabilities as a military strategist and competent captain:
‘That was but a trial,’ said Faramir. ‘Today we may make the Enemy pay ten times our loss at the passage and yet rue the exchange. For he can afford to lose a host better than we to lose a company. And the retreat of those that we put out far afield will be perilous, if he wins across in force.’
Thus, "resigned" speaks to his character, going forth to do his best, better than the term "despairing", which implies throwing his life away for no good reason except maybe to gratify his father somehow – which also does a disservice to Denethor IMHO. Faramir strikes me as too well-grounded to be a people-pleaser, if that makes sense. (Don't get me started on how the filmmakers distorted Denethor's portrayal for dramatic flair or whatever their reasons were...)
Author's reply
Lin!
Not to worry. I like SPAM. well spam from you, the other kind is meat for the truly desperate! LOL! This is a lengthy response and written after a fashion like the Literature essays that I wrote way too many of at University, which strangely I enjoyed writing???
I like the idea of Faramir’s acceptance of assaulting Osgiliath likened to Frodo’s acceptance of the Ring journey. I think that "resigned” is a good description of Faramir. But that is the emotion that I think Faramir in the film is displaying when he and his riders are leaving Minas Tirith.
Also that is what I hear when this exchange happens: “So be it,’ said Faramir.
‘So be it!’ cried Denethor. ‘But not with your death only, Lord Faramir: with the death also of your father, and of all your people, whom it is your part to protect now that Boromir is gone.’
‘Do you wish then,’ said Faramir, ‘that our places had been exchanged?’
‘Yes, I wish that indeed,’ said Denethor. ‘For Boromir was loyal to me and no wizard’s pupil. He would have remembered his father’s need, and would not have squandered what fortune gave. He would have brought me a mighty gift.’
For a moment Faramir’s restraint gave way. ‘I would ask you, my father, to remember why it was that I, not he, was in Ithilien.” His father has admitted that he wished that Faramir had died and not Boromir.” In the film you see the impact that has had on Faramir.
The relationship between Denethor and Faramir is not good and the film shows that, but in shorthand.
During that meeting of the captains Denethor keeps mentioning the loss of Boromir, “It is at Osgiliath that he will put his weight, as before when Boromir denied him the passage.” and after the continual mentioning of Boromir in the meeting the day before quoted above and in this meeting the exchange happens:
“But I will not yield the River and the Pelennor unfought - not if there is a captain here who has still the courage to do his lord’s will.’
Then all were silent, but at length Faramir said: ‘I do not oppose your will, sire. Since you are robbed of Boromir, I will go and do what I can in his stead [italics mine]- if you command it.’
‘I do so,’ said Denethor.
‘Then farewell!’ said Faramir. ‘But if I should return, think better of me!’
‘That depends on the manner of your return,’ said Denethor.
This happens in a roomful of people, granted and all were silent. But through Denethor’s repeated mentioning of Boromir, knowing the close relationship between the two brothers, seems to me he is goading Faramir to act.
Faramir takes the statement personally “‘I do not oppose your will, sire. Since you are robbed of Boromir, I will go and do what I can in his stead.” So much is at work here. Faramir is grieving, his restraint tested to its boundaries. His loyalty and his duty are once again are called into question by his father and this time in public before other men of honor. Even if Denethor wasn’t necessarily goading him specifically, he takes it as such.
Then Faramir make response that to me as an avowal of himself yearning for some acknowledgement from his father of what he is about to undertake:
“Then farewell!’ said Faramir. ‘But if I should return, think better of me!’
And he receives a complete rebuff.
‘That depends on the manner of your return,’ said Denethor.”
Even though he knows this mission is doomed to failure, he undertakes it. Why. As you say Faramir too well grounded to be a “People-pleaser.” And under normal standards I would agree but his life has been torn to shreds. His brother has died. How and why he has received conflicting reports. His father who is also grieving Boromir’s death is roundly once again questioning his second son’s decisions and loyalty and his very survival at this point. Is Faramir resigned yes, to what though. That is the question. I think the film shows this well. Faramir is riding to his death. Does he want to die? I don’t think so but his life and his choices are leading to this unenviable position. Is it a rational decision? No. But it is one that he may see as inevitable. Does the film make more of it than the book, possibly but the drama of it in cinematic terms for me is devastating and very memorable.
I think PJ and crew do more of a disservice to Denethor than Faramir. I completely regret that they did not give John Noble the line “I sent my son forth, unthanked, unblessed, out into needless peril, and here he lies with poison in his veins.” It shows a realization of what he has done and also later on his love shown through a broken mind but he will allow no one else nearly hoping he will speak in the end.
He sent his son and now grief and guilt (and the Palantirr) have broken his mind. He knew Osigilath was a lost cause and yet he sent Faramir anyway. By his own admission, he sent Faramir. Denethor’s mind aided by the Palantirr drove him to this. It is tragic. And Denethor in the film is given none of this. He is angry, raving. Except at the last when Faramir is coming to while on the fire and Denethor sobs, "My son!"
But enough of my ramblings! Onto Ch. 41!
(((hugs)))
MM