Very thought provoking... I really enjoyed it, and I think you captured the emotional turmoil of the parents well. I do not have children, but have a friend with a handicapped child - their daughter has Downs Syndrome, and I saw my friend go through the denial, the guilt, even anger. She found out while she was pregnant, and was thankful - once she came to terms with it. She and her husband (and extended families) did an amazing amount of research so they could help their little girl be the absolute most/best she could be. My friend sometimes calls her daughter "God's child" because, she says, Ella is so full of love, joy and compassion that she is a constant reminder of God's unconditional love.
I really liked your into to the story, too - particularly the first line: "Everything and everyone is perfect in the Blessed Realm... is it not?" Of course! Everything and everyone is perfect...each for their purpose. Since only the Creator knows the true purpose of each part of his creation, who are we to judge?
I won't offer an opinion of canon, as LOTR and The Hobbit are the only works of JRRT that I've read so far, but I did enjoy this tale. I think this would be great expanded to see how ada comes to accept his child fully and help her to fulfill her potential!
Author's reply
Thanks! Well, but so far I have no idea... That is why I asked help from the readers. :)
*wince* Well, I am a blind, and until now I am adverse to the word "abortion" when applied to a pregnant woman... Such thought did not cross my parents' minds, I think, because they only knew that I was blind when I was born, but imagination is sometimes a curse. And I am lucky here that I am not rejected by my parents, although my father is often sceptical of my abilities. :) I had a friend whose mother aborted her second child (my friend's new sibling) because of an inner bleeding. The doctor said that the child would be born handicapped if it were born, and so the parents took the... short cut. That was a very unpleasant tale to me, and my imagination once again run rampant.
I did intend the summary of the story to intrigue one to think about things, at least slightly, before they went into the story itself. I am glad that it seemed to work. :) It is also my belief that only the Creator knows what His every creation is meant to be, and to Him they are all perfect. That was what I hoped to convey by the summary of the story. I also read somewhere that in Sindarin "hope" has two words: expected hope and faithful hope. This is a story set in Aman in The Silmarillion's timeline, true, but I would like to convey that message anyway. Faithful hope is a fool's hope, but it is stronger and in a way truer.
Glad you enjoyed the piece! I do not know if I will manage an expansion, though, as I said before. My muse refuses to cooperate with me... Perhaps your muse would be so kind to help mine? Anyway, thank you for your sharing a part of your life, your thoughts, and your comments.
- Rey