Grey Wonderer
· 29 July 2008
· Chapter 1: Back Again
I really enjoyed this. It's a brilliant first fiction. I hope you intend to continue writing. The more hobbit stories the better.
Author's reply
Thank you, for reading, and taking your time to comment. I'm glad you liked. :D
Antane
· 29 July 2008
· Chapter 1: Back Again
This is your *first* attempt?! Dear me, what a wonderful job! I am first and foremost a Frodoholic (or more accurately FrodoandSam-holic) but I do so love Pippin also, particularly since I am he/he is me in my circle of friends, Frodo and Sam being already taken. :) So thank you for this! Write more! Like a sequel to this or anything else!
Namarie, God bless, Antane :)
Author's reply
First attempt at fic in this fandom, yes. (: I've been writing fanfiction on and off in various fandoms for years now, although less lately. It was great to delve into LotR. I used to be a Frodoholic (with added bits of Frodo/Sam at times) but the interest sort of cooled for the sake of Pippin. Generally I love all the hobbits though.
Thank you for your kind comments!
Larner
· 29 July 2008
· Chapter 1: Back Again
Such a beautiful tale, Maaya. Several of us have done our takes on Pippin awakening again, and this is a wonderful addition to the genre. And welcome to SoA!
Author's reply
Thank you for the comment and for the welcoming. :D I've read many lovely stories in the genre, but for some reason it has always nagged me that I wanted it to happen "MY way" instead. Hence, I wrote.
Agape4Gondor
· 29 July 2008
· Chapter 1: Back Again
Great first tale! Congrats...
I loved how you easily flowed from the present to memories of the past. Well done.
I loved the humor too.
Hope you enjoyed the writing as much as I did the reading and hope to see more of your stuff here.
Author's reply
Thank you! I did enjoy writing it, and I'll hopefully have time and inspiration to write more. :) Thanks for commenting.
Envinyatar
· 29 July 2008
· Chapter 1: Back Again
Lovely. A very realistic account of Pippin's awakening.
Author's reply
I'm glad it feels realistic. Thank you for reading and commenting!