Reviews (14)

Llinos · 20 July 2007 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

Hi Littlefish Re MEFA Nomination Just a quick reminder that your story still needs to have the form filled in. When you've done that, could you let me know that you're happy with the form and then I can set your story to "nomination complete". I can see you have worked on the form but you only have until this Sunday afternoon to complete it and get back to me. Excuse me writing here, but I was worried you had not got my email. Thanks a lot! Liza (llinos)

Llinos · 4 July 2007 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

Hi Sorry to contact you here, but I don't seem to have had a reply from you about the MEFA nomination for this story. Could you let me know if you want it to compete? Many thanks Liza (llinos) Lizallinos@aol.com

Llinos · 14 June 2007 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

Hi Your story has been nominated for the Middle-earth Fanfiction Awards 2007. I am your liasion, but I have not heard back from you yet, and am wondering if you received the email notification. I would be grateful if you would contact me asap to let me know if you would like the story to be included in the awards. Many thanks Liza (Llinos) Lizallinos@aol.com

storyfish · 24 May 2007 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

This was rec'd by Marigold and I had to stop by--wonderful story! I'm a Pippin fan myself, so I admired his Legolas-saving heroics and loved that scene when he's left behind to watch their baggage, Pippin bored and angry and annoyed and yet oh-so-Pippinish. Some other things I loved: Malek was a great eeeevil villian. Truly scary. And Arwen was magnificent--I love that she refused to be left behind.

PipMer · 22 May 2007 · Chapter 6: Awakenings

I love this story so far! I found it through a recommendation by Marigold. She mentioned it once again for those of us late to the fandom. The action sequences are great, and the descriptions are lovely. I can feel the fear that grips Aragorn as he confronts the evil elf for the first time. Wonderful!

PipMer · 22 May 2007 · Chapter 6: Awakenings

Eilenach · 9 April 2007 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

Great plot, great dialogue, and everyone is in character. The re-introduction of Galadriel's star was unexpected, but made perfect sense. Up until that point, I had wondered how you were going to defeat Malek.

vampfan30 · 17 May 2006 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

All I can say is "wow". this story had me on pins & needles!!!!

Meimi · 9 February 2006 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

I know that this story is a bit old, but it's still one of my favorites. I first read it on ff.net, but unfortunately, can't seem to get its stupid review windows to work properly, thus I was ecstatic to find it posted here. It's really just such an awesome story, the drama is both touching and edge of the seat wondering what's going to happen next, and the action is just marvelous. I especially adored your portrayal of Pippin (and he isn't even one of my all time favorite characters), and everyone else was just wonderfully in character as well. Overall this was, and always will be, a lovely read, and certainly an excellent reread (again and again and again).

docmon · 25 September 2004 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

Terrific story! I'm so glad I found this when you already have the sequels written! I'm looking forward to it. Great action, and I loved how you gave the reactions of all the characters. And you switched perspectives so that we'd know what was going on with all the characters throughout. I loved getting those bits of humor that you managed even in the most dire circumstances, like the way Gimli and Aragorn got Legolas to talk. LOL! I did wish to see more of Legolas's recovery; it seemed glossed over a bit. But perhaps you didn't want to focus on that. I'm just a sucker for recovery and closure scenes. I'm so glad there's more. Ready to go on to Hostage of Hate! monica

Bedivere · 6 July 2004 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

The story line is great, the phasing is great, everything is grand. Hope you still have more of this.

sofia · 7 January 2004 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

I came across this story on an authors favorite list. I love this story! I will now be turning to read your other story " Hostage of Hate" Im glad that it is a sequel!!

PartiotElf · 6 December 2003 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

There are no words... to describe how....completely, totally.......AWESOME ( for lack of a better word) This story is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I loved it! I even printed it out!!!!!!!! I want to be able to read it over and over!!!!!!!! This is the best!!!! I read this a long time ago, and now that I figured out to post a reveiw.... THIS ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I've read Hostage of Hate too, and they both are soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! plus Legolas is my favorite character! You rock!!!!!!! I want more! Your reader, Erin P.S. Can't wait for the sequal of Hostage of Hate!

Luinielle · 4 November 2003 · Chapter 28: Bright Horizons

This was the very first LoTR fanfic that I ever read and it is, to me, still one of the best. I remember when I found this (after slogging through story after story on fanfic.net and despairing that I'd ever find something other than Mary-Sues) staying up all night reading all 28 chapters in one sitting because I could not put it down! From the very beginning, it grabbed my attention and would not let go until the very end. This is a story I can read over and over and always enjoy with the perfect mix of angst, action, and humour. Your original characters came to life and had so much personality, they were a joy to get to know. Some authors are very good with descriptions (the way they describe things, you can see it perfectly in your mind, whether they are places or people or moods, etc.) and other authors are very good with dialogue. You have the gift of being able to do both. Wonderful, wonderful story! Looking forward to reading more fics from you! (I am halfway through Hostage of Hate - will review once I am done!)