Reviews of A Quadrabble for Sam

Bodkin · 9 June 2006 · Chapter 1: A Quadrabble for Sam

What a moment for Sam to find himself back in the middle of all the horrors! He is so caring though - even coming back to himself, he will not distress Arwen by letting her know what she has said. And Faramir knows something is amiss - but is tactful enough to remain quiet. Fingers crossed that Aragorn manages to sort this out. I wouldn't want Sam to be deprived of his taters once he gets home!

Author's reply

Dear Bodkin.... Thanks so much - but dearest Sam is so unassuming that he wouldn't even think that he had distressed Arwen. Too little. Just a Hobbit. She must be upset about something else. Strider only came 'cause Arwen called him - but it couldn't have been for him! I just love Sam.... Oh - now you've made me think about taters and the Shire - poor Sam!!! Though I'm sure he'll take it in his usual pragmatic way. Swallow and dig.

French Pony · 8 June 2006 · Chapter 1: A Quadrabble for Sam

Poor ol' Sam. This has a nice "slice of life" feel to it -- just another day in the utterly abnormal life of a hobbit with PTSD. It's sweet and sad and horrifying all at the same time.

Author's reply

Thanks, FP, for the kind remarks. This started out with the thought that it would be a light 'gardening' moment and quickly went downhill. As life does sometimes! Many thanks, again, for your comments!

Linda Hoyland · 8 June 2006 · Chapter 1: A Quadrabble for Sam

I think it very realistic that Sam might have distressing flashbacks.I loved the way how the greatest in the land rushed to care for Sam.

Author's reply

Thanks, Linda, for the comments. I think the Fellowship, by this time, was terribly attached to each other. They could not bear another loss. And King or no, Aragorn, and all of M-E are beholding to this 'Ringbearer!'

Lindelea · 7 June 2006 · Chapter 1: A Quadrabble for Sam

Well put-together and believable. Gentle Sam, not wanting to distress Arwen. Faramir, remembering Boromir, but sensitive enough not to correct Sam's statement. Aragorn, understanding even though he doesn't understand, agreeing with Sam. I do hope that healing will come. And practical Sam, already figuring out a workaround. Thanks!

Author's reply

Thanks, Lindelea, for looking at each one of the characters and their response. And I enjoy the word 'workaround' - it fit Sam, doesn't it!!!

rabidsamfan · 7 June 2006 · Chapter 1: A Quadrabble for Sam

Ouch. That would have hit hard, wouldn't it. Poor Sam! I love Faramir and Arwen and Aragorn trying to figure out why...

Author's reply

Thanks - great praise from a Sam fan - I don't usually write about the dear. A poem challenged me! It was supposed to be a cute little thing - when Sam stepped in, put his foot down, and said - 'Don't toy with me, woman!' So we get angst... and *blushes* a pretty neat scene, I'm surprised to say. Thanks again!

shirebound · 7 June 2006 · Chapter 1: A Quadrabble for Sam

Oh my, poor Sam! He has his memories, too, doesn't he? This is a wonderful scene, full of love and tenderness.

Author's reply

Thanks, Shirebound - I so admired your writing! Thanks for enjoying 'my' Sam - though only mine for a moment....

Reviews (6)