Reviews of Merry's Magnificent Yule

Grey Wonderer · 20 January 2013 · Chapter 1: Merry’s Magnificent Yule (also known as Naked Yule!)

(Sighing in relief, Merry was happily relieving himself in the coalscuttle.)LOL Tonight, I was on line messing about and reading some of my older favourites and came upon this one. I know I reviewed it on the challenge site but that was a while ago. Anyway, just wanted to let you know that I still adore this one. I was laughing out loud as I read it. Thank you for giving me so much entertainment this evening. And I know you won't see this for a while since your internets are sick, but it felt wrong to enjoy this and not say so. Cheers!

Larner · 20 May 2006 · Chapter 1: Merry’s Magnificent Yule (also known as Naked Yule!)

Merry OWES Pippin for this Yule! And I love the song of the knickers. Very hilarious! And you managed to get the nakedness and the coal scuttle and all in there very well! I truly love this challenge of Marigold's.

Author's reply

The song is great, isn't it? Llinos is brilliant at songs and poems especially. I am glad that the story made you laugh! I had so much fun writing it! I am so glad that Grey Wonderer inspired this Challenge!

Bodkin · 18 May 2006 · Chapter 1: Merry’s Magnificent Yule (also known as Naked Yule!)

Poor Pippin. The things you do for your friends!

Author's reply

Yes, Pippin tried to be very grown-up and sort of pay poor Merry back just a little for all the care he's given Pippin over the years, but it was not pleasant! But I know that he didn't regret it at all : ) Thank you!

harrowcat · 17 May 2006 · Chapter 1: Merry’s Magnificent Yule (also known as Naked Yule!)

Oh I agree with BB's every word! Including the bit about laughing too much to review last night. I do pity whoever is going to have to do the cleaning and washing a Brandy Hall! And I can see the pictures and hallways being regaled with that wonderful song.

Author's reply

Thanks! I am so glad that you enjoyed the story and it made you laugh! That makes me very happy : ) I'll bet the servants at Brandy Hall get paid extra for cleaning up after parties, lol! The song is great isn't it, and so very hobbity! Llinos is amazing!

Baggins Babe · 17 May 2006 · Chapter 1: Merry’s Magnificent Yule (also known as Naked Yule!)

*wheeze* *gasp* By the time I'd finished reading this I was giggling hysterically and my sides ached. The bit about the coal scuttle completely finished me. Marigold, this was priceless! Thank you for making my evening. I delayed reviewing until this morning, simply because I could not have strung two coherent words together! Oh dear, poor Merry - what a state to get himself into. And poor Pip, having to deal with it. I can only imagine the hangover the following morning. Ow! Terrific story - I always think hobbits know how to enjoy life. Now I'd love to be invited to the next Brandy Hall party..........

Author's reply

Wow, thank you so much BB! I am really glad that you enjoyed it and it made you hysterical, that means a lot to me! Poor Pippin, trying to be the adult for a change, and having to deal with so much! I think he managed very well : ) The parties at Brandy Hall are awesome I think, quite excessive in every way! This is a wonderful review and I appreciate it very much!

Reviews (5)