Reviews of Stories Beyond the Havens-Part II

Nella · 8 September 2006 · Chapter 4: Peace at Last

You killed two people within a four chapter story!! I'm impressed :-) I can't kill people easily. Poor Mel. I hope you continue her story! I'll have to look at you page for more Mel fiction.

Author's reply

Yeah, I know *feels guilty* I've done that before in one of my novels, but I didn't have the heart to keep them dead, so I did a funky fantasy thing, and had them come back to life (don't you love fantasy?) I don't have any more Mel-fic yet, but I will soon! I loved her! (btw-her name is my other nickname in elvish) God bless, Ellie

Nella · 8 September 2006 · Chapter 3: The End

In the prequel to this I half-thought that Frodo and Mel were goingto fall in love and get married. I guess I was half right. They did love each other dearly. I'm sorry for Mel and Sam. I know they must miss Frodo awfully.

Author's reply

I considered that, but nothing ever came of it. She was his very good friend though. They were almost as close as Frodo was with Sam. God bless, Ellie

Nella · 8 September 2006 · Chapter 1: Bad News

Dying?!?! You're going to kill Frodo? Well, I suppose it had to happen some time. I just can't believe it. He seems like one of those characters that will never die, no matter what happens to him.

Author's reply

I know, it sounds frightening doesn't it? I still can't believe I wrote Frodo dying. *tear* God bless, Ellie

Goldberry Apple Blossom · 19 March 2006 · Chapter 4: Peace at Last

Okay, you now have made me cry, and I'm tying to get ready for Teen Pact and everything! You really did a wonderful job on that story. What a good ending for two very heroic charicters. God Bless, Gold. See you later!

Author's reply

Why thank you dear! I am very sorry to cause you grief in the midst of tremendous mental strain.....Jk!! LOL! glad you liked it! Little Frodo-lad was very upset with me about this story, but I posted it anyways. God bless, Ellie

harrowcat · 19 March 2006 · Chapter 4: Peace at Last

I enjoyed this Elanor. But it is so very sad! Perhaps you could add a re-union chapter.

Author's reply

Glad you enjoyed! I was thinking about a re-union, but I really don't know if I could write one that isn't lame. And I really don't know much about the after-life in Middle-Earth, other than that there most likely is one. Thank you so much for reviewing! God bless, Ellie

Arwen of Lorien · 18 March 2006 · Chapter 4: Peace at Last

Goodness me, It took me this long to notice! Since I share your name there is another name that I recognized, clever! I practically fell off my seat when you (ahem) said that part about Frodo dying, I first thought, no! I had enough of that finishing a certain Inky book. But then, it turned into a lovely story, sad but *sigh* very, very sweet. I caught the Very good part you put in as a comfort to Sam. Hope others catch that too. Over all, a very good addition to your stories. Such a good writter! C U later mellon nin! Namarie & God bless, Arwen

Author's reply

Oh, yes, well, that certain Inky book would also make me not want to read any more about characters dying. *Ahem-dustfinger-my favorite* But I am glad you liked it, mellon nin! C U later! God bless, Ellie

Queen Galadriel · 18 March 2006 · Chapter 4: Peace at Last

*sob* Oh, Ellie, it's so sad, but a peace comes with the sadness. I like to think of Frodo and Sam going together, as in Larner's stories, but I like your version as well. Very well done, indeed, and you really got me crying! God bless, Galadriel

Author's reply

Thank you very much! I really did like Larner's version as well, but I didn't want to sound like a copy cat. I am glad you liked it! God bless, mellon nin! Ellie

Reviews (7)