Reviews of Returning Shadows

Speedy Hobbit · 3 April 2007 · Chapter 1: Darkness

Leave it to Shirebound and her plotbunnies to produce truly brilliant stories! Of course, a talented writer opting to take on the challenge does help things rather a bit, does it not? =) I just love the description of the "Elvish wisdom" Sam discerns at the denouement of the piece... and how you depict Sam's dashed hopes upon discovering that the illnesses would indeed plague Frodo annually, and jsut... I could go on positively forever! Write on, Periantari, write on!

Author's reply

Wow Speedy Hobbit, this is a very flattering and encouraging review that you've left! Thank you so very much for liking this story so much. :) I've always loved Frodo fics that pertain to the anniversary dates and was glad that i had the right inspiration to have me write a longer story out of it. You've picked up on a part that i like a lot too--and i'm glad that you enjoyed this as much as I enjoyed writing it. :) Cheers to you to and i hope to read some of your stuff in the near future as well. Again, thanks so much for your kind words. :)

Claudia · 2 December 2006 · Chapter 1: Darkness

Aww...Thank you for reccing this for me! I really wondered if there were fics that were centered around that scene of the Oct. 6th anniversary. And you did a lovely job of bringing that to life! Poor Frodo! *loves him* :-) *hugs*

Author's reply

I love h/c around those two anniversaries... lots of "h" though lots of "c" as well could be written...so it's a very tough time fro Frodo but you can see his inner strength as well. I wish to write more of these. ;) THank you for liking this! :hugsback:

Lotrgirl1415 · 22 January 2005 · Chapter 1: Darkness

loved it...wished it wouldnt end! --Katie

Author's reply

Katie-Thanks so much for your kind comments. They really do make my day. =)

Nivina · 11 January 2005 · Chapter 1: Darkness

I can re-read this story over and over again, and I always get lost in it. It's so vivid, and you do the h/c very nicely! *awwwww's* :)

Author's reply

awww thanks for liking and leaving me another lovely review for it. ^_^ i'm glad you like my kind of h/c... i always try not be too overly cruel to dear Frodo and provide LOTS of TLC fro him. ::hugs::

esamen · 8 January 2005 · Chapter 1: Darkness

“I will always be here for you, Mr. Frodo,” whispered Sam as he opened the door a little, to see his master’s face shine with Elvish wisdom within, calm and peaceful like one who has passed on to a more serene place beyond the shadows. Oh! Oh! This is beautiful! I have never read a fic like this before! Wonderfully done! thank you, thank you! I hope you write more. Please start typing right now! I can't wait to see what wonderful stories you have in your talented heart!

Author's reply

awww thanks so much for the lovely and encouraging review. This is so much appreciated and i'm glad that you found this story beautiful and wondefully done. :blush: thanks so much and yes, i am still writing another short story and a work in progress.... will post asap. Thanks again for the very kind review, esamen. =)

Reviews (5)