Periantari · 15 January 2005 · Chapter 1: Why Must This Be?
i love Bilbo angst especially regarding Frodo taking on a burden that used to be his... I am glad that it is written about~ good job :)
Why Must This Be? by Beruthiel
Reviews (4)
Lindelea · 31 December 2004 · Chapter 1: Why Must This Be?
Powerfully written, with nice use of details. The lads walking about with unlively steps, too old for Quests, innocents paying for others' mistakes, saying goodbye with his eyes, can't watch them walk away, swallowed by shadows. You paint a vivid word picture in this little glimpse.
Author's reply
Thanks! Nothing like a review from one of my favourite authors to brighten up my day. I'm flattered!
Hai Took · 30 December 2004 · Chapter 1: Why Must This Be?
Oh! That was wonderful! The way you caught Bilbo emotion and the difficutly of saying good bye when he feels so responsible for everything! Looking forward to the others!
Author's reply
Thanks for the review! I hope to post the next one in a few days, as long as my muse doesn't desert me.
DAYNA · 30 December 2004 · Chapter 1: Why Must This Be?
How wonderfully poingant that was! Poor Old Bilbo! You really nailed that one, Beruthiel! Beautiful little ficlet. You made me tear up at work! So not good! LOL Thank you for this lovely insight.
Author's reply
Thank *you* for the lovely compliments.