The Golden Bell of Greenleaf by lwarren

Reviews (176)

Write a review

daw the minstrel · 12 November 2005 · Chapter 17: The Gift of the Sea

The relationship between the elves and horses is wonderful. I especially like the way you show it from both sides. But my favorite part of this was the image of the elves and horses playing on the shore. Aragorn is right. That sight will soon be gone from ME. The analogy of the pool on the shore is an apt one.

Author's reply

I am glad the relationship between elves and horses is still satisfying. I dearly love playing with them! :-)...from both sides! A romp in the waves and sand seemed called for after such a traumatic night - and both horses and elves needed some relief and relaxation! (me, too!) Of course, when Aragorn said it was a sight not often seen and soon to be gone, I was sad all over again. As for the tidal pool, I fought with that - I was going to put it in...then I wasn't...then I was...then not...until I finally just closed my eyes and left it in. I'm glad it worked. Thank you for taking time to send your reviews, daw. I am always so encouraged by them! linda

Alassiel · 12 November 2005 · Chapter 17: The Gift of the Sea

The chapter was lovely and moving. The description of Aman was beautiful and made me long to go there. Arador is a very wise being. He almost seems like a Maia in disguise. I am very glad that Legolas is beginning to know the value of his place in Ennor and that the Song of Arda is undivided. I loved the play of the Elves and the horses and the lesson of the tide pool. Thank you for this. I hope real life lets you update soon. Almië, Alassiel

Author's reply

Alassiel, you make me want to cry! Thank you for reviewing, especially after already wading through this a couple of times! Arador is very wise - the idea of him being a Maia in disguise is fascinating...though he's not! I, too, enjoyed the play on the beach, especially after such a tense night and day before. I am also glad the lesson Arador imparted at the tidal pool was apt - he was looking for a way to tell Legolas and Aravir what he thought they needed to realize. Thank YOU for this review, my friend. As for real life and updates - you will be pleased to know that I am well into ch. 18 already! Can you believe it? (I can't!) linda

Bodkin · 12 November 2005 · Chapter 17: The Gift of the Sea

Oh good. Hand-rubbing time. So pleased to see this. Do you know, I love Arador. He seems to have a remarkably deep understanding of elves and their reactions - and the Song - for one who is only very distantly connected to them. And in Calen and Raen, too. The way they decide to stay with Aravir and offer him their unspoken support is splendid. Aragorn makes a great horse-minder. (A new role for him, should he get tired of king-ing and ranger-ing.) Aravir and Legolas have built a whole new relationship of mutual support now - with this twist of events. They will probably be very useful for anchoring each other - I hope Legolas can share his new insights with his friend to see that all is part of the same whole. “Is it found in the Song, my lord?” Legolas nodded. “Yes, partly. But perhaps, with your permission, it would be better if I showed you.” Aravir smiled. “Proceed, hir nin.” As he bowed his dark head, the first lilting notes of a song he had only imagined drifted through his mind, and he willingly gave himself to the beauty and majesty of the music. What a night this must be, listening to these two sharing their versions of the song - I would think that none of those hearing this will return unchanged. And the elves and the horses playing in the water - what an image! It is just so beautiful and light-hearted. I'm not surprised they all settled down to watch. Then again - Arador is just so knowledgeable! And understands better than the elves themselves what they need to understand. By himself he is enough to let the elves know that there is value yet in staying to learn more of Ennor. I'm so pleased to see this - and look forward to finding out more.

Author's reply

You know, Bodkin, I have the same response when I see one of your reviews! You have no idea how encouraging and timely they are! I appreciate you taking the time to send one! Arador - I have envisioned his character as the white-haired, wiser than usual elder from the beginning. He's just extremely perceptive about people in general, and given his background and knowledge of elves, well, I just figured he would have some words of wisdom to impart to them (if he ever thought they might be needed.) Calen and Raen are grandsons after his own heart, too, and Aravir saved Raen's life. Calen is not likely to forget that. Coupled with Legolas saving their father's life - they have become quite attached to these two fascinating beings. So even when Daeradar frowns mightily on their staying to watch over Aravir, they do it anyway! Loyal young men! Aragorn minding the horses - he's had a time throughout the story getting Arod to halfway trust him. I think his care here finally proves to Arod he's all right - for a man! I liked the way he kept messing with the mare, though!:-) Sharing the Song - I only wish I had been there to hear it! *sigh* Mutual support - yes - that is exactly how I see this developing! Aravir had kept himself aloof for the years previous to this little adventure. Now, not only does he have his duty towards the Prince, but friendship has grown as well. They will be good for each other, I think...they understand what's happening. An elven romp in the surf - everyone sure needed some respite from the pain and drama of the night and day before (me, too!). I'm glad you enjoyed it - I certainly did! ;-) Arador wants them to understand the elves' value to all of Middle-earth - not just to Aragorn alone. He wants these two to endure and realize that they are appreciated, as well as meant, to stay. I am so glad you enjoyed this! Thank you again for taking the time to review, Bodkin. I can actually say that more is on the way, maybe sooner than later this time! LOL linda

Manderly · 11 November 2005 · Chapter 17: The Gift of the Sea

Oh you are writing again! How nice! And a very satisfying chapter! I am so glad that Legolas is now moving closer to a state that he can perhaps live with the sea longing, but now I am worry for Aravir. Hopefully his sense of duty and loyalty to Legolas will help him cope with the longing. The scene of the two of them, and the horses, frolicking on the beach was just wonderful! I am still amazed at the horses though. When Legolas and Aravir returned to them after the night in the tree, Arod was acting like a neglected wife giving the cold shoulder to the husband who had been out partying all night! I am beginning to like Arador more and more and I am sure I am not alone in this!

Author's reply

Hello Manderly! I'm so happy to hear from you - thank you for taking the time to review! Yes, Legolas is becoming more and more able to deal with the sea-longing when it really starts tugging at him. Aravir, unfortunately, has also heard the call of Elvenhome now, but I think these two will help each other immensely. They know what is happening to the other and Legolas has been given some insight into coping with the call through the Song. He can share that with Aravir, who, as you say, will stay beside his Prince out of sheer loyalty and friendship. I'm glad you liked the horses - I had to laugh at the way you saw Arod acting - he did come across as somewhat of a 'nag', didn't he? LOL But you and I know that he has reason to fear for Legolas' health when the sea-longing swamps him - maybe in the future he won't be so freaked out about it! ;-) Arador is an interesting and lovely old man, isn't he? I'm glad you like him! Thank you again for reviewing - it is so great to hear from you again! :-) linda

Rose Sared · 11 November 2005 · Chapter 17: The Gift of the Sea

Very nice to see you back in print! A chapter full of lovely visions, elves singing in trees and finding truth, horses and elves playing in the sand and surf, the meaning of life in a rock pool. The mare still has no name, it reminds me of a song - hah! I hope Aravir manages to keep Legolas company, that last grey ship is growing into a bit of an ocean liner, aye? Nice pictures of Aragorn caring for his friends and the horses too. Yum, well done Rose

Author's reply

RS, hello! Yes, shock!, here I am! I think I was more surprised than anyone! :-) I'm so glad you enjoyed the visions in this chapter - it was one of truths being spoken and maybe recognized/embraced for the the first time. (Even a beautiful, immortal elf needs to know he's appreciated!) I had tons of fun envisioning that romp in the surf - tempted even this old mare to go back in the water again! LOL As for the horse with no name - I suppose it's a good thing this doesn't take place in the *giggle* desert...that would really call for a chorus or two, or three... Now, Rose, I want you to pay particular attention to ch. 18 when it finally gets posted (actually, I'm well into it already *gasp*), ok? All will be revealed, preciousssss, I promissesssss! (She should have been named 6 or 7 chapters ago, ya know, but I got sidetracked! Senior moments strike every 5 minutes, I'm told.) Poor sweet mare - having to put up with Aragorn messin' with her ears, and me messin' with her identity! It's enough to make her apply for early retirement, ya know? It was so nice to hear from you again - thanks for the review (yum!) linda (rs, you make me smile...)

WindSinger · 27 September 2005 · Chapter 16: Linhir

Oh, another wonderful chapter! It takes me forever to carve out the time to send even a brief review but I really wanted to let you know how much I enjoyed this chapter. Although, I think I want to be a member of Luinaelin and Arador's family so I, too, can rub elbows with Legolas, Aragorn, Aravir and the Gondorian guard -- lucky them! You have done a great job of developing each family members character. I just love their spunk, honesty and love of life! And the sea! The way various members of the group (especially Legolas) respond to their first glimpse of the sea are very -- understandable and believeable. Wonderfully done! And now, don't tell me that Aravir is taken also? Well, maybe he and Legolas can work out how to live with it together. And poor Aragorn! He knows Legolas agreed to stay as long as he lives but it must be VERY hard for him to watch his friend suffer. I am sure Aragorn is anxious for some kind of resolution, or at the very least a truce between Legolas and the sea longing. Loving this story and anxiously waiting for more! WindSinger

Author's reply

Oh the utter embarressment of it all! I finally updated with Ch.l7 and discovered I had never replied to your wonderful review for 16! My only excuse is I cannot reply on the computer I have the most access to, and I'll leave it at that! But what a wonderful review and I so appreciate that you took the time to send it! I know well the feeling about being able to 'carve out the time' to not only send reviews, but to update, as well! I'm so glad you are enjoying the characters - they have taken on lives and personalities of their own...I just operate the keyboard and follow instructions! LOL I must admit I struggled a bit with Legolas' first physical glimpse of the wide open ocean - after all he had it in his mind that he had found a way to deal with the call (though there were still twinges). But facing the open sea and merely being somewhat aware of it on the Anduin are two different things. I would think the sheer scope of the ocean would be breath-stealing, particularly for two sensitive elves like Legolas and Aravir. Yes, Aravir has now awakened to the call of Elvenhome! As to whether he and Legolas can help each other deal with it, well, one can only hope! And Legolas does have the knowledge imparted to him by Nienna earlier...that should help, especially if passed along to Aravir! We'll see... As for Aragorn, he is completely torn...he hates, in the worst possible way, seeing his friend suffer and yet he absolutely dreads the thought of Legolas sailing...It is a dilemma that will haunt him until the end, I fear...(sniff!) Thank you again for such a wonderful review, and again, I apologize for the tardiness in replying! linda

eliza61 · 13 September 2005 · Chapter 16: Linhir

Hi lwarren, What a great chapter, I was waiting patiently (ok maybe not so patiently) for the next adventure. Oh poor Aravir, I think he's been bitten. I'm starting to take a dislike to the sea, (not a good thing for a gal who lives on the eastern seaboard) its taking all my favorite elves! I hope he doesn't leave Legolas, he's good for him. I really enjoy how all your characters care for one another. Until next time, I remain Your fan Eliza

Author's reply

Thank you so much for the encouraging review, Eliza! I'm sorry to take so long to respond...Rita has taken a great deal away from everyone where I live lately! (I'm thinking a storm moving inland from the sea should be experienced by our elves in the next chapter..Lord knows I've seen enough of them lately! LOL) The sea awakens that intense longing to 'go home'...it is not to be ignored, and one can only hope it can be dealt with. With Legolas, we know he's been given a tool to help him live with the call. Aravir? Well, we will have to see...you are so right, too - he is good for Legolas and it would be a terrible shame if he ended up having to sail. I hope to update more quickly this time, Eliza, if the weather will stop messing around! :-) Thank you so much for your review! linda

Rose Sared · 12 September 2005 · Chapter 16: Linhir

Shees baaack! Goody, and so polished, throughout the good nature and relaxation of this chapter there was this continuing threat, the sea the sea, and now it has struck - again. Great stuff, greatly enjoyed. Rose

Author's reply

Hello, Rose! Yes, finally! I'm glad you enjoyed the chapter (I thought it would never get done!). I'm afraid that the sea will continue to be a problem for Legolas, although he will learn to deal with it (as has been decreed...his time to leave has not yet come. He is still too important to the reign of a certain King.) As for Aravir, yes I'm afraid the sea-longing has struck again. As to the intensity of it, well...we'll just have to see, won't we? Thanks for reviewing, Rose linda

Bodkin · 12 September 2005 · Chapter 16: Linhir

I'm so happy to see this back. I've been thinking about Legolas and his horses. What a good read it is, too. I had forgotten just how delightful Erelas's family is. I love the picture of Laurelin shaking her head at the innocence of the king's guards - as she threatens them with a small blond boy. And the first sentence is lovely. Sets the tone for the rest - which is also chockful of terrific images. The town. The sea. The night. Wonderful mind-pictures. So Legolas is busily trying to hide his feelings, is he? Surely he doesn't think he's going to get away with that, not with even the horses prepared to watch him. His greed for the peach was such a lovely contrast to his usual etherealness - and brought him back a bit, too. Perhaps a sample of the strawberry crop might have an effect as well. Love the town - trees? Shrubs? Boxes of flowers? Only one incurable downside as far as I can see. The smell of fish. I like Thoron's family - and anyone who cooks well enough to encourage elves to over-eat must cook exceptionally well. And I can see Legolas's reasoning - too much time in Thoron's company and Arador would have cracked ribs for sure. As soon as Aravir said - 'don't worry about me, I'm fine' - the 'oh-oh' button was pressed. I hope he doesn't descend into irreversible sea-longing. Although it would give Legolas someone in sympathy with his plight. But, on the other hand, Aravir would have less reason to struggle against it and stay and then Legolas would get more depressed and then . . . I hope you are feeling inspired to continue. I enjoyed the feast.

Author's reply

Hello Bodkin! Not half as happy as I am to finally have finished and posted it! :-) I'm so glad you enjoyed it...that it read well and kept your attention. Erelas' family is a lot of fun to write, and Laurelin threatening the two guards with a certain blond youngling, I thought, was very much in keeping with Brethilas, the resident terror! (He's much more, of course, but at his age, the 'terror' side just seems stand out, for some strange reason! LOL I hope I didn't overdo the mind pictures - you know how wordy I get *sigh*, but once I started describing those places, it was hard to quit. I was assured that it was ok - not repetitive or awkward, etc., so I left them in. Wasn't that peach scene funny? Sometimes I get tired of the Prince being all ethereal and 'princely', so I have him do something somewhat out of character. I always hope it's not too much. But Legolas was trying, at the time, to draw his friends' attention away from him. I suppose he really does think he can get away with it. He forgets that Aravir was around to watch him grow up, practically...and of course, there's Arod! Yeah, the town was pretty...and fishy. I'll bet when the wind is just right... Thoron was one of those "let me have my say" characters that just insisted on his place. Big and boisterous, poor old Arador didn't stand a chance! :-) I suppose even an elf would appreciate a finely prepared meal, and I thought the menu sounded quite gluttony-inspiring! ;-) Yes, things might get a little sticky for Legolas AND Aravir for awhile. I'm so glad you found the 'feast' enjoyable, Bodkin! Thank YOU! linda

Manderly · 12 September 2005 · Chapter 16: Linhir

Ooops, I think I screwed up with the review the first time I sent it. Obviously my mind wasn't fully functional at the time. Please go ahead and delete it so I am not reminded of my senility. Anyway, I am so glad to see this story again! And such a long chapter! Thank you! I really hope that Aravir isn't succummbing to the call of the sea as well, but it doesn't look too well right now. And I am holding my breath to see how it's going to affect Legolas when he at last comes face to face with the sea. It still gives me a little jolt each time the horses "speak". I'm beginning to see them as real live characters now. Hope you will update soon!

Author's reply

Manderly, you are not senile! Consider that review gone! I'm so glad you enjoyed the chapter (it was almost novel length, wasn't it?). It took forever to finish, it seemed like. As for the sea-longing, it doesn't look too good for Aravir, does it? We'll just have to see how strongly it's going to affect him. Legolas, meanwhile, must reconcile the song of the sea in Arda Marred with the song of Aman. Once he succeeds with that, he'll be much more in control, tho' it will still entrance him, I fear. I love the horses, too. Especially my Arod. He's just such a good and loyal friend to his elf. I actually have started the next chapter...let's hope it (and RL) won't be so cantankerous this time! Thank you again for the wonderful review, Manderly. linda

daw the minstrel · 12 September 2005 · Chapter 16: Linhir

Well, yes. Aravir. And he hasn't had Legolas's years to learn to deal with it. Will that make it worse, I wonder? Or does the longing grow worse with time? Legolas seems to be living with it now. He's not over it, of course, but he seems to have fitted it into his life.

Author's reply

Hello daw! You are so right - Aravir hasn't had Legolas' years or experience in dealing with the sea-longing. You asked some very pertinent questions, too. (Questions I've been thinking about...like are there degrees of the sea-longing? It would seem that some elves might be more strongly affected than others...I've always wondered how Cirdan was able to stay for so long. It is 'a puzzlement'!) I guess we'll have to see just how strongly the sea has affected Aravir. Legolas should be able to help him - I hope! Thank you for the review, daw! linda linda

Bodkin · 12 September 2005 · Chapter 16: Linhir

What beautiful descriptions - and lovely interactions between the characters. I shall have to go and read it again. I'll get back to you later.

Author's reply

Goody, I'll be waiting to hear from you! (What was this...an appetizer?) And the first review, too...you'll have me holding my breath, Bodkin! :-) linda

The Karenator · 22 May 2005 · Chapter 15: See With New Eyes

I'm sorry it's taken me so long to review. I finally slew that pile of ironing today! This was a delightful chapter. If I didn't know that you're a teacher, I'd think you had surgical experience. You did a very nice job of describing Aragorn's skill with his ME scalpel. He even sterilized it in the flame. I don't guess they knew about germs, but it's always seemed to me that simply being clean was common sense. Somewhere along the way, someone must have figured this out. If anyone did, surely Elrond knew and Aragorn learned healing at his knee. Seeing Aragorn take precautions made me feel better anyway. Your Aragorn comes across as kingly and kind. He seemed to set the pace for this chapter. Everything was calm and under control. The king was as much a tonic for everyone as he was a physical healer. Even Legolas was glad to see him despite the fact that Aragorn did not follow Legolas's directions to allow him to go on alone. Fortunately, Legolas recognized Erelas's need for Aragorn's healing abilities and he accepted that he also needed his friend. Very nice. The ending where Arador told Legolas his story was something of a surprise, but this revelation gave me the sense of things coming full circle. It made sense. Sort of the 'it's a small world' kind of thing. I love how you've written this human family. The personalities are distinct and feel very real. I can even see the differences in their culture compared to the culture that Aragorn is used to in Minis Tirith. That's a nice touch. Arador was certainly perceptive about Legolas. He's a kind and gentle man who simply wants to help. There are more ways to offer healing than a poultice. I like the way you've brought all these people together and I like the bond that's formed between them. Indeed, they are all a part of the whole. I get the feeling that you're winding this story down. I hope there's a few more chapters to go. I've enjoyed it so much that I hate to think about it ending, but at least I know I can come back and reread it. So, carry on. I'm really looking forward to the next chapter. Karen

Author's reply

Hello Karen! Ironing? Ick. Almost as bad as a forest full of big, ugly spiders...and have you noticed how a pile of ironing takes on a life of its own and MULTIPLIES? *shudders* Glad you defeated the evil, tho'. :-) "If I didn't know you're a teacher, I would think you had surgical experience." LOL Well, thank you! :-) That really has me grinning, Karen! Yes, you know how teachers are - combination nurse, counselor, nana, ada, good cop, bad cop, and now surgeon! *grins foolishly* As for Aragorn and germs - hmmmm, I didn't think about him sterilizing the knife and that it might be out of place (and time). I guess as a writer of LOTR fanfiction, I'm a product of all the other stories and descriptions I've read of Imladris with plumbing and everything. And I suppose Elrond, being a very clean elf, would insist on cleanliness when dealing with illness and injury. He taught Aragorn well...yes, he did! :-) Aragorn did kind of take over here, didn't he? I like you see him as calm and in control. He arrived at a rather chaotic time for everyone else and had to get everyone calmed down! Legolas, I think, got over his irritation with his nosey friends when Aravir showed up. And with Erelas so ill, he was so glad to see Aragorn he just conveniently overlooked everything else! Thank you so much for commenting on the differences between the family here and what Aragorn normally sees in Minas Tirith, and I'm glad their personalities are coming out more clearly. I've gotten rather fond of this bunch of humans myself! So, their background surprised you? Good! And Legolas is finding out how small the world really is as he travels on...full circle...I like that! As for the story winding down, yes, you are right...two more chapters(I think...but who knows!) or possibly three. But I have to tell you, Karen, the initial plan had this story only going 7 chapters! So who knows? Certainly I do not! I'm glad you are still enjoying it, though. Thank you so much for taking the time to review, Karen, especially after that traumatic battle with the ironing! linda

eliza61 · 20 May 2005 · Chapter 15: See With New Eyes

What a tender, lovely story. You're writing is great, all the characters emotions come across strongly & vividly. Your supporting characters are really interesting. I like the way that they contribute to my leggy's well-being. He seems to be learning from every one around him. It's funny how even though the elves are thousands of years older than the grandfather he still manages to teach them some thing. Looking forward to the next update. Eliza

Author's reply

Hello, Eliza! Thank you so much for the very kind review. I am so pleased and encouraged when I read that someone finds the characters in my story interesting, and that the emotions come through! "I like the way they contribute to my leggy's well-being." He's so endearing, you know? (Of course you do - what a silly question! LOL) I just see him as being a caring elf, one who made a difficult decision to stay in Ennor in spite of the sea's call, and all for the love of a friend. His caring attitude invites others to care for him in return. Legolas is indeed learning a lot during this story, and not all the lessons have been easy. And it seems lately that everyone he meets has something to impart to him. Arador, in particular, is a wise old man with a strong, discerning nature. I like to think he sees the "big picture", while Legolas is rather focused in on his own pain and longing. You're never too old to learn, I guess! :-) Thank you again for taking the time to review, Eliza. linda

Dot · 20 May 2005 · Chapter 15: See With New Eyes

Hey there. Great chapter. Even if I was wincing for a lot of it! Giant splinter? Ouch! Aragorn is excellent in the way he remains so calm and manages to be soothing even while cutting into Erelas. I also like the way he gets Arador and Laurelin involved so they can feel they have done something and at the same time keeps them busy enough that they aren’t focusing on their anxiety. You sound very knowledgeable about all this healing stuff, Linda. Did you research it all, make it up, or know it already? I was rather glad to see more than just the astonishingly useful athelas involved!! My heart went out to Arador when he allowed himself to think of all that might have happened had Aragorn not turned up. I like the way Aragorn speaks to him so firmly, knowing that’s really the only way to get through to him. Gentle words of comfort were unlikely to even register with him. “Well, I had the advantage of growing up amongst elves who delighted in racing through the trees.” LOL. Not an image I associate with Imladris but one I’m quite happy to dwell on ;-) I could have told them that tea is the answer to everything. It wouldn’t even have to be dosed with anything if they had some chocolate :-) I was a little worried about Raenor. I’ve become very fond of him! I had to laugh at Aragorn’s surprise to hear who was responsible for the stitches! And it’s great to see the twins together. Methinks Aravir is becoming quite attached. I thought the little conversation between Aragorn and Aravir was very touching. Their concern for Legolas is wonderful but it’s also good to see the same worries anyone would have: “Was he angry, Aravir?”!! I love the fact that it’s Arod’s decision whether or not Aragorn will get a chance to speak to Legolas! Dead right. I absolutely adore the moment where Aragorn silently begs “Please…please let me have the right answers for him.” *sigh* That nearly broke my heart. I felt quite bad for Legolas in his realisation that the sea-longing had merely changed, not disappeared. But his strength is amazing and I’m so, so glad that he’s finally decided that he can’t do this alone. Besides, I like this gang too much for you to split them up again! “The next day became one of celebration, for Erelas awoke complaining loudly about his stitches and his poor, starved self.” ROTFL! Men! They’re all the same. I’m glad to see him starting to recover, though. Elena and Lissiriel are wonderful now that they’ve overcome any shyness. They’ll be in love with Legolas for ever after all he’s doing for them! Oh, how I loved the scene between Arador and Legolas. They seem to have a gift for being able to comfort one another. “We’re part of a whole, ye know,” Arador whispered. “Part of the elves…distantly, yet still a part.” Aha! I figured. The story is fascinating, although tinged with a sense of sadness that so many great love stories have. I can’t tell you how much I love the idea that it’s Arador who makes Legolas see not only the great need for Legolas to remain with Aragorn but that his strength and ability to stay is due to Iluvatar himself. It adds a wonderful dimension to the importance of Elessar’s reign and, of course, to the friendship between them too. I’m delighted that Aravir finally knows the full story too. Oh, and Arador could be the perfect person to have along for Legolas. He’s wonderfully perceptive. “Legolas grinned at the sight of the King of Gondor looking up at him like a rumpled, disgruntled owl.” LOL! That has to be one of the best images in fanfic! Marvellous chapter. I hope your class of killer squirrels will be getting their holidays soon so that teacher can focus on more important things… Right, back to work for me… ;-)

Author's reply

Dot! Hello! Gee, did I make you cringe? *sighs with satisfaction and salutes* Mission accomplished! :-) No, seriously, if it got that reaction from you then I actually got the picture across I was aiming for. Erelas was in a pretty bad way! So, you liked Dr. Aragorn? He needed Laurelin and Arador halfway calm so they could help him out. Since they were healers, I could see him talking his way through the procedure to keep their attention on him, and not on what he was doing. "You sound very knowledgeable about this healing stuff..." Naaaah. I have a basic knowledge gleaned from my childhood and my children's younger years! (and numerouns trips to the doctor) :-) I once had a thorn driven into my heel that eventually worked its way out the other side of my foot - it was the weirdest thing I ever saw...I was lucky it didn't get infected like Erelas' wound did. As for the herbs and plants, I found this cool website on the historical uses of herbs and plants in medicine. It had all kinds of plants listed, along with the ailments they were used to treat, what part of the plant was used, where they grew, when they were harvested...all kinds of stuff. I figured Aragorn was a well-rounded healer with knowledge of all medicinal plants, compliments of Elrond. While he might use athelas a great deal, I could see him using other stuff, too. LOL to the tea and chocolate!! The cure-alls for everything that ails you! As for the tree racing elves in Imladris...I guess I was thinking of visitors from Lothlorien or Lasgalen...I suppose Imladris elves were too civilized! ;-) You mentioned a lot of my favorite parts - Raen and Aravir's obvious care for the twins (he likes kids - he practically helped raise his little sister and the other elflings that survived his settlement's attack). Arod continues to guard his elf, and Aravir is more at ease with Aragorn, isn't he? He's learning to lighten up! *g* Erelas is just like every other sick man - whiney! LOL Meeting the King gave him a start! Elena and Lissiriel will indeed remember Legolas with heartfelt sighs and giggles for years to come! (smart girls!) Yes, the call of the sea has changed. In some ways, this new song is more dangerous - more beguiling, like a Siren's song, instead of so demanding as it was at first. I struggled with that elven connection to Arador's family for about two weeks. I wanted it believable, but wasn't quite sure how to go about it. I'm glad you liked it - I remember another review where you were going "hmmmmmm, I wonder?"...about that family. :-) Arador is very insightful and will prove a valuable companion for this little trip. And LOL is right to the sight of the King as a disgruntled owl! My class...you know, I had them tamed for awhile...but alas, all good things must come to an end! Four more days and then I can breathe! (and concentrate on this story!) Thank you for a wonderful, comprehensive review, Dot! linda

Bodkin · 20 May 2005 · Chapter 15: See With New Eyes

Blow it. Spelt écureuils wrong. Too early in the morning.

Author's reply

I tried blowing on this, Bodkin. I still don't know what it means (spelled right or not!). So, translate...please? linda

Bodkin · 19 May 2005 · Chapter 15: See With New Eyes

Ah, les ecureils meutriers. They do cause problems. I am in awe of a school year that ends in May. We go on until July. Late July. And then the government - who would like schools to exist as childminders for working mothers and ensure that teenagers are kept off the streets - is always going on about how bad it is for children to have a long summer holiday of 5-6 weeks. And our kids tend to start school at 4. (Of course, private schools have shorter terms - and no-one seems to worry about that.) Enough on the subject. Loooovvvely chapter. Gorgeous interactions. The worry over Erelas. (Just as well that Aragorn turned up then with his healer hat on.) The information about healing. (Birch leaves? Really? I never knew that. And comfrey. So it's not just the magic athelas.) The whole family are delightful - remotely elven too. That would explain a lot. Do they tend to marry in their extended family? That would keep the bloodlines strong over the thousand years or so. (I reckon that the natural tendency of nobles to marry nobles is what kept the Numenorean strain strong in Gondor - and also the elven line of Dol Amroth. The whole social system is probably a mass of sixth cousins marrying. There's probably a whole department in Minas Tirith University keeping track of who is legally allowed to marry whom.) I found the operating really interesting and very well-done. And Aragorn is so reassuring and warm and teaching as he goes. A credit to Elrond. The humour adds to the feeling of relaxation. I like Jarrod - he is clearly concerned about Aragorn and glad to see him feeling better about this. (It's a charismatic leader who can make soldiers and chance met families care about him.) And Aravir and he clearly have something in common that makes them friends - their care of a certain prince. The Horse Protection Squad. Magic. And Arod decided to let Aragorn through - once he knew his place in the scheme of things. I like the viewpoint that Legolas is helped to stay because he is needed - and have you somehow been reading the Reflection that isn't published yet? Because I think that you might recognise an echo of a sentiment expressed here! Arador is very perceptive. He will make a good companion on this journey. I'm looking forward to finding out how Legolas deals with the sea. And to more about Arador's family. Excellent chapter.

Author's reply

Oh Bodkin! You poor thing! School until the end of July? (Where are you?) I would perish (no, actually, I would retire!) We also tried the year-round school thing and do you know who didn't like it? The parents! Seems it interferes with vacation time! I am assuming your "les ecureils meutriers" has something to do with my class of murderous tree rats! (I'm not feeling very charitable towards the little darlings right now!) As for government interference, I think they should TEACH in a classroom before they pass these laws...it might broaden their outlook on some things. 'Nough said! :-) Thank you so much for the very kind words about the chapter! As for the use of birch leaves (and bark)... when Legolas was hurt, I thought I'd better look up some stuff besides the willow recipe and found this neat website on the historical uses of herbs and plants in medicine. I was surprised to find birch and oak trees mentioned (excited, too). I figured a well-taught healer such as Aragorn would make use of whatever he could, as well as his favorite, athelas. I always thought that it was in the King's hands that the true power of the athelas plant was released...he could make use of other plants as well...maybe! :-/ But he is a credit to Elrond...and making the procedure with Erelas a learning time kept Laurelin and Arador halfway calm! I'm glad that Jarrod and Aravir are starting to come through more as characters. Jarrod has a story somewhere...I'll have to look for it! As for the Horse Protection Squad (lol) - aren't they great? Arod is his usual cautious, protective self where Legolas is concerned! Oooohhh! Have I hit on something in a Reflection to come? I can't wait to read it! When, Bodkin, when? :-) You are right, Arador will prove very helpful on the little sojourn to come. He's very insightful! You know, we just might make it to the sea in the next chapter! LOL Thank you again for the review, Bodkin. linda

daw the minstrel · 19 May 2005 · Chapter 15: See With New Eyes

I love how noble Aragorn is here among these people of his who live so simply and are of such a distinguished descent. Wealth and standing don't seem to matter. And now we see these people helping Legolas in return. I also like your deeper explanation of why it's important for Legolas to stay for Aragorn. That's a good question when you think of it.

Author's reply

Hey, daw! Aragorn in the books always came across as such a noble character. I couldn't see him treating his people differently based on where or how they lived. He just seems too kind for that (at least, to me!) I suppose all his years in the wilderness as a Ranger would make him immune to the trappings of wealth and standing, tho' he's seen and lived both (as a Ranger and at Imladris)...good training for a King, it seems! As for Legolas staying, I tend to lean heavily on the friendship aspect of the elf and the King's relationship. So little was revealed about it in the books...I just like to think that they would both give up a great deal for each other. And Aragorn had quite a job ahead of him in reunifying the two realms - a HUGE job, plus dealing with all the consequences to Middle-earth caused by Sauron's existence over the past ages. He will need all the help and support he can get - someone constant in his life (he will live longer than most of his mortal friends from the War) he can go to for encouragement, advice, or just to use as a sounding board. So, Legolas is 'helped out' with his problem in order to stay for the hundred and twenty-odd years that Aragorn is King. (It makes sense when I think it...but when I try to verbalize it, well....) ;-) This is a LOOOONNNGGG reply - but your observations were very thought-provoking. Thank you for taking the time to review, daw! (Still working on that 'fundraiser' for Mr./Mrs. daw's trip to Hawaii, especially since you sent Flower Face to see her Daeradar, bless you...LOL) linda

Manderly · 19 May 2005 · Chapter 15: See With New Eyes

Oh goody, another chapter! I've heard of many reasons for delays in posting, but killer squirrels? Did they chew through the computer wires? Amazing how a little splinter can almost take a life. I am glad Aragon got here in time to help Erelas. If anything had happened to Erelas, Arador would be overwhelmed with guilt. I can imagine Erelas' shock when he finally wakes up and realizes that he has been tended to by the king, no less. I am so glad that Legolas is now agreeable to having his friends with him and admits that he does need their help. I like the scene between the lovely king and the pretty elf. I can clearly picture the pretty elf, but "lovey" king? Hmm, will take some pretty liberal imagination. So they are off to the sea now. Looking forward to that. Please don't keep us waiting too long.

Author's reply

Hello, Manderly! Let me explain about said "killer squirrels"...I teach a room full of wiggly, giggly, squirrel-ly third graders. We have six days of school left, tho' for this bunch, school was 'out' two weeks ago! LOL It has been absolutely crazy! But I escaped! Yay! I had a friend who had a rose thorn in her hand and within a week had blood poisoning - her mother told us that the doctor said thorns were the worst for that sort of infection. Now, I didn't look it up or anything, but I remembered that time even now, years later, and decided to use something similar for Erelas' injury. It had to be quick and toxic and hard for Arador and Laurelin to spot at first...and you're right, guilt would have almost destroyed Arador if anything had happened to his son. (I imagine Legolas would have shouldered some of that guilt, too, since he initially cared for the man.) Manderly!!!! You don't think Aragorn is 'lovely'? ;-) He is King now, and I'll bet he cleans up real nice...picture the crown of blue flowers! *sigh* Besides, Legolas had to tease him somehow to get back at Aragorn for all the 'pretty' remarks. Seems to me the King is just asking for another skin of water to be dumped on his head! LOL I promise (I hope) that the next chapter will appear more quickly, now that school is almost out and I'll have some time to actually sit down and concentrate on the story! Thank you for taking the time to review! (Keep trying to imagine that 'lovely' King...) linda

Ninna · 19 May 2005 · Chapter 15: See With New Eyes

Yay! An update! I just discovered this story a couple of weeks ago and it was so good I read straight through and then sought out "Through The Years" and read it, too. Lovely writing, just lovely...I so enjoy your evocative way with words. You have a great talent. Now I will try to wait patiently for the next update...no pressure, just eager for more!

Author's reply

Why thank you so much, Ninna! I am so glad you found the stories and enjoyed them. That really means a great deal to me. As for 'talent', well, let's say I'm working on it... and having a lot of fun doing it! :-) Again, I appreciate you taking the time to review and encourage. Hopefully, the next chapter will come more quickly than this one did (school and a snag in the story *sigh*). Thanks again. linda

Dot · 20 April 2005 · Chapter 14: The Nature of Hope

Oh... such a beautiful chapter… I’m completely intrigued by this family, who speak Sindarin, know the tales of the elves and seem familiar with the notion of sea-longing… Hmmm. Interesting, eh?! I loved Aravir bonding with the donkey at various points in the chapter! And I thought the little moment when he sends Legolas off to the trees was very moving. I just love the way he seems to understand that something important happened to Legolas and even suspects what it may have been but never questions him and is just there to support him and give him the space he needs. I don’t blame Aravir for being worried about Legolas. It is worrying that the sea is calling to him so strongly again. Thalion and the mare??! Aaaaw :-) It must indeed have been an amazing moment when Aravir appears in this family’s yard. I thought Calen’s defensiveness was rather endearing. He’s very perceptive too. They’re a wonderfully close-knit family. I was surprised when the whole lot of them headed off to help Raenor and Erelas – but it really shows their closeness. I like Arador, and the way he and Aravir reassure one another. I particularly liked the moment between the horses and Legolas. He’s a lucky elf that so many are concerned about him, but in a way it makes it sadder that he has all this love and yet it just won’t help in the end. I thought it was very telling of the relationship between Legolas and Arod that not only would Arod refuse to let Legolas brush aside his concerns but isn’t as easily reassured as the mare seems to be. I’m becoming very fond of Laurelin too! She’s a perfect mixture of strength and gentleness and even in such a worrying situation she brings comfort and humour. I just adore the way you manage to make your characters so well-rounded and believable. The children are marvellous too and little Brethilas in particular seems to have brought much-needed life and energy to the group. Aravir seems to come alive around the children too. He’d make a good father. “He would not lose this son.” There’s something very poignant about that simple sentence. Has he lost another son? I guess nearly everyone has during the war. I think, though, that what’s particularly touching about it is that it is not for himself that he wants to save Erelas but for Laurie and the children. I love how respectful Arador is of Legolas and Aravir, knowing something is amiss. There’s the suggestion too that Aravir senses this, because I doubt he’d very willingly share that moment with many people, or allow his concern for Legolas to be so open. And the image of the loyal captain and friend silently watching and listening brought tears to my eyes! Can you reassure me that he won’t be affected by the sea??! I know he probably won’t but I’d hate to think he would be. Actually, I don’t think I could bear that at all! Erelas really sounds in a bad way. I’m starting to fear for him. He needs more help than even these healers can give him. Someone like… oh, look!! It’s Aragorn!!!Yay!! Woo-hoo, I’m up to date!! Again, I’m sorry it took me so long; I honestly never thought it would. But I’ve loved every second I’ve spent reading your story and eagerly await more :-)

Author's reply

Hey Dot! *Woo-hoo, I'm up to date!* You are so funny...and I am SO not "up-to-date" on anything right now! *jealous sniff* :-) Thank you for so faithfully reviewing these chapters and sending such detailed, encouraging reviews, too! Sooooo, you are intrigued by a human family that seems well-versed in things elven, eh? Good, you and one other have voiced that observation...just as I intended (now, if I can ever write it the way I imagine it...). The donkey seems to have struck a chord here - but I've noticed the small ones are so sweet-natured and oh, trusting, I guess would be the word and so this little gray beast reflects that. Hmmm, he really needs a name now...gee, thanks, Dot...another name! (*note to self - name the donkey...and while you're at it, name the mare, for goodness' sake!*) Aravir is finding that while he noticed things as his Prince's commander, he's really noticing a lot of little things as his friend. Yes, the sea-longing is NOT gone, only somewhat alleviated. Yep, I can just see a colt or filly with those two as parents....*sigh*;-) I hesitated to send the whole family after Raen and Erelas, but Arador would go (son and grandson) and of course, Laurelin for her husband. I couldn't see leaving the kids behind alone, especially seeing how the house was so isolated and they probably were going to be gone overnight (even tho' Calen is 15, he's still not much protection) so, it quickly became a family camp-out! I'm glad the horses and Legolas are friends - the mare is still learning to recognize Legolas' worries...she senses his disquiet and it bothers her, makes her feel insecure. But Arod, now, he's been with our elf for over a decade and he knows him pretty well. He is not put off by simple "I'm ok" reassurances and he loves his elf too much to just let it go. A true friend indeed! I'm glad you like Raen's and Erelas' family. They are good people with an interesting past, and Arador has lost many loved ones, as you caught in that one little reference. More on that in later conversations! Brethilas is a live wire - he keeps them all hopping! :-) Eruanneth asked also if the sea might not be dangerous for Aravir and I can honestly say that right now, he's ok, to my way of thinking. But then, this story has taken so many different paths...what's one more........... *vbg* (You guys really should keep those pesky bunnies of yours to yourselves!) "He needs more help than even those healers can give him. Someone like...oh look!! It's Aragorn! Yay!" Now Dot, did you ever REALLY doubt that Aragorn would ever be able to stay away? He just decided it was time to make a kingly tour of the south and just happened to be in the neighborhood...you know how those things are! LOL And just in the nick of time, too! Thank you again for reviewing, Dot...I get such a kick out of reading and then replying to them! You make me smile - yesssss, you do! linda

Dot · 15 April 2005 · Chapter 13: Finding Common Ground

This chapter was so engrossing. There I was, really feeling for Erelas and thinking how selfless and brave he was to give his son the best chance of survival by risking his own life and then I read: “Raen closed his eyes and let go of the branch.” Linda!! I was not expecting that… Whew, there’s Aravir. I love the way he knew immediately how Legolas would react and leapt into action himself. He must have been just as shocked as I was when Raenor fell into the water! What followed was… well, picture if you will, me with one hand on the mouse, the other having its nails chewed off. Aravir is such a hero! I love that elf. You made me smile with Raen’s reaction the appearance of the elves. There’s something very endearing about that boy, even when his head hurts! Erelas sounds like he’s in a pretty bad way. I’m still cringing at the thought of his wounds. My heart went out to him as he lay there, not knowing what had happened to his son. Believe it or not, I’d forgotten about the mare there for a moment! She’s doing very well. This situation must indeed have made her very nervous and I just love the way you’re showing her slowly building up the trust in Legolas that Arod has. And speaking of Arod… look who’s here! As ever, he’s showing a lot more wisdom than his flighty elf ;-) My favourite moment in this chapter was Arod explaining Aravir to Legolas. “Do not be angry that love brought us here to you.” *sob* That’s so lovely. So, I take it horses don’t use people’s names, eh? If I’m not careful, I’ll end up calling Aravir “the other one” too! The reunion between Aravir and Legolas was done so well. I loved the hesitancy mixed with determination on Aravir’s part and Legolas’ delight in surprising him. I think they really needed that moment between them, and I was so glad to see it. Ack! There are people waiting for Erelas and Raenor to return! There are so many twists and turns in this story – which is always a good thing! And you have this uncanny knack of getting me to care about all these characters who keep popping up along the way! :-)

Author's reply

Hello! I am so glad I surprised you! :-) Raenor knew his father would sacrifice himself and decided he stood a better chance of surviving (being younger and all!) So the brave lad let go...and almost caused the elven equivalence of a heart attack in Legolas and Aravir, not to mention his father just about fell apart! LOL I see you were gritting your teeth right along with them, Dot! Erelas is hurt pretty bad, tho' the wound pierced clear through and didn't damage any internal organs, it bled a great deal and left fragments of dirt and wood behind. Not good! Yay, Arod! He doesn't hesitate to take Legolas to task when he senses his irritation at being followed. How can you argue with love being the driving force behind their disobedience? You can't, and our dear Prince knows it! (Ah, you caught the way Arod doesn't use names, did you? And neither does the mare! I'm having to think about that - Arod especially would be familiar with the names of those he's been with for the last 12 years...tho' he calls Gimli the "small, loud one" and knows that Aragorn is the unkempt one! ;-) I may leave it as is...just have to be careful and not slip up when writing...) I'm glad their friendship is finally establishing itself, too - Legolas isn't one to stand on ceremony but he needed Aravir to cooperate a little! Yes, there is a rather large, concerned family waiting for Erelas and Raenor to return. I'm so glad you don't find that the new characters detract from the story! They appreciate the kind thoughts, too. LOL And I appreciate the wonderful review, Dot! Thanks! linda

Bodkin · 13 April 2005 · Chapter 14: The Nature of Hope

This is just such a gorgeous chapter - with plaintive bits, yet full of hope. And the cavalry arrived! Equipped with sacks of athelas, I hope. What did I enjoy most? Aravir and Legolas's budding relationship. Their horses' budding relationship. The thought of beautiful foals! Legolas's singing - although I am a bit concerned that he has bitten off more than he can chew here. Certainly a good thing that the cavalry is here. But then Erelas's family is a plus - and twins, too! (That should bring back recollection of a certain pair of elven twins to brighten their memories.) And that little brother should prove an attraction - elves being a soft on little children as they are! Daeradar seems to be a good one as well. As is the donkey. Although he doesn't, I expect, speak Sindarin. Actually, I just loved the whole chapter - the feel of it was just gorgeous. And I think this family will do Legolas a lot of good. He seems to need to feel part of a family from time to time - and this is a good bunch.

Author's reply

Hello Bodkin! I am so glad that a feeling of hope came through. Things were rather rough for everyone there at the end! And of course, the cavalry came...and I'm sure Aragorn never travels without a store of athelas (sacks? *vbg*). I thought Legolas needed an elven friend...he has all these very dear mortal friends that just worry him sick. He needs a friend with a more permanent feel...who'll help him through the eventual sadness of the others. I kinda liked the thought of a big, lovesick Thalion being ignored by the mare - and beautiful offspring - love was in the air, definitely! ;-) Legolas only thought he was out of the woods where the sea-longing was concerned. He still has some things to learn, tho'. Yeah, I wanted a big family - twins seemed cool (hey, I'm partial to twins for some reason!), so enter Raenor and Calen. Brethilas is the sparkle, and Arador the anchor for them all. The donkey does not speak Sindarin, but I'll bet after an introduction to the elves, he's willing to learn! LOL I'm so glad you liked the chapter, Bodkin. Gorgeous? Coming from you, that's quite a compliment! I think you're right, too - Legolas needs to feel a part of a family, especially when he's troubled. This family will be good for him. Thank you so much for reviewing! linda

The Karenator · 12 April 2005 · Chapter 14: The Nature of Hope

Twins! I guess Aravir thought he was seeing double. Erelas and Raenor's family was great. You've done a terrific job with the mortal folks you've introduced us to. I liked the family's reaction to seeing an elf, but as soon as they found out that the kinfolk had been hurt, they were all business. The camp scene was nice. All the kids nestled in their...bedrolls and Grandpa keeping watch. Frisky horses with love on their minds. :>) And just as things were beginning to look dire, the cavalry arrives! I was so excited to see Aragorn...armed, of course...riding in. Your build up to this was just perfect! You used few words, but they were the right ones. In only a few sentences, I could feel the tension rise and then I wanted to stand up and shout: "The king! The king is coming!" But I was afraid I'd scare the dogs.... This was so much fun. I really enjoyed this chapter. Karen

Author's reply

Hey Karen! Yep, I love twins (don't know why....hmmmm). I'm glad you liked the family of our two injured friends. They seem to be good people. So, you liked the camp scene, eh? I would love to camp beside a stream in a beautiful wood with elfsong in the background...*sigh* Frisky horses? Only one - Thalion has some convincing to do before the mare will even look at him! LOL Yes, the King has come...armed, of course...with sacks of athelas (according to Bodkin, and I'm still grinning over that mind-picture of Aragorn weighted down with sacks and sacks of his favorite healing herb!). Your last paragraph was so encouraging...I tend to get really wordy...chatty...verbose...long-winded...whatever! when I write and for you to say that I "used few words, but they were the right ones. In only a few sentences, I could feel the tension rise..." well, Karen, I had to mark this down as a day to remember. Now I can tell myself, "you can do this...you can say in a few sentences what you want and not take 3 pages!!!!!" LOL Really, I am terrible about that! But now there is HOPE... Thank you so much for this review, Karen, and I'm glad you didn't scare the dogs! :-) linda

Manderly · 12 April 2005 · Chapter 14: The Nature of Hope

So nice to see another chapter! I think I've told you before, but I really love your "ordinary folks". They add so much warmth to the story, especially the little ones. Legolas is being affected more deeply by the sea now and that is cause for concern. At least he has three nursemaids at his side, Aravir and the two horses. The horses are fretting as much as Aravir. And now that Aragon is here, Legolas will be surrounded by nursemaids. Thank goodness! A very enjoyable chapter and hope to see another one soon.

Author's reply

Hello Manderly! I'm so glad to hear from you. I'm glad you liked the family in the story...they do seem to add a lot, and I love writing the little kids. They're my favorite! (besides elves, that is) ;-) Yes, my poor Legolas only thought the sea-longing had loosened its grip on him. The calm before the storm, I guess...He is going to need his friends plus a few new ones to finally understand how to really deal with it. LOL "surrounded by nursemaids"... no wonder he gave orders for them not to follow! But he'll be glad eventually that they did! I'm glad you enjoyed the chapter and thank you so much for taking the time to review! linda