Auntiemeesh
· 13 June 2004
· Chapter 1
This is a lovely account of the wizards' arrival in middle earth. You've really captured the nature of each wizard with just a few words :)
Author's reply
Thank you! I thought for a long time about how much to reveal and so on, so I'm glad that it worked :)
Kitt of Lindon
· 12 June 2004
· Chapter 1
Ooh! Ooh! Cirdan story!!!!
This was very well done. I had wondered if someone had written a story about this particular moment, and yes!, I have found it. The manner in which the Istari landed in Middle-earth is beleivable. The descriptions that Cirdan places on them reflects his wisdom.
This is going on my favorites list. It makes my day to find a Cirdan story, but it's even better finding a really good Cirdan story as this. ;)
Author's reply
I got it up just in time, then :) I'm so glad that the story seemed to fit with canon: I'm never quite sure if I've got things entirely right.
Thank you! Círdan fans seem to be few and far between...my sister wondered how on earth I managed to actually write a story about him :P