Rosie-Ann · 12 May 2004 · Chapter 1
*sniff* Oh, wow...I teared up there... Wonderful work.
Lost Sons by SoundofHorns
Reviews (4)
Hai · 11 May 2004 · Chapter 1
*sniff* How sad for these fathers' to see their sons so transformed by their newly acquired past. Very touching! Thank you!
Lily Belladonna Took · 11 May 2004 · Chapter 1
Very well done, but quite sad as well. The differences in dialect are very interesting, and help lend character to each voice. Does it go: Paladin, the Gaffer, Saradoc? If so, then the description of Samwise as a wolf is both fitting and frightening.
Author's reply
You're correct--it's Pippin, Sam and Merry. However, I deliberately did it so it could go different ways. I'd imagine Sam would be somewhat frightening to the Gaffer. He left a gentle, shy hobbit and came back virtually a warrior.
Lindelea · 11 May 2004 · Chapter 1
Ah, how poignant, how sad! Pippin... Merry... Samwise? How much you say in how few words!
Author's reply
Well, the first was definitely Pippin, but the last two could have gone either way. Interesting that you see Merry as the wolf instead of Sam.