Samwisegirl12, who is too lazy to login
· 12 July 2004
· Chapter 1: Everything
wow. I am floored. That is one of the sweetest, cutest, well-written, heart-felt fics I have read in a long time. I love how you applied the song to all of the hobbits. ah, hobbit love - so cute! Frodo's reaction was so sad. Poor guy is all alone. I wish he could have married. BRAVO!!!!
~ swg ~
Author's reply
"I wish he could have married." Oh, me too. Though I couldn't have asked for a better ending than The Grey Havens. Thank-you!
Pervinca
· 22 March 2004
· Chapter 1: Everything
Oh, that was very good! I don't know which mini-fic I liked the best, but I'd probably venture to say Pippin's, with him being my favourite character. However, I thought that Frodo's little piece was particularly well done, because it was so different from the others. That was a very clever idea to work the same song - that had been so wonderful to the other three - to haunt him. Great work!
Author's reply
Thank you! Pippin's part was so fun to write. I'm glad you liked Frodo's part. It feels really strange though, writing three happy fics and then switching to dark. Anyway, thank you so much for reviewing!
Pearl Took
· 21 March 2004
· Chapter 1: Everything
Poor Frodo . . . but awesome! What a twist to your love story. Most excellent!
Author's reply
Thanks! I've always wanting to try something jarring. Glad you liked it ^_^