Reviews (443)

Fimbrethel · 25 October 2025 · Chapter 99999

I see. It was good! And the ideas were as well!

Fimbrethel · 25 October 2025 · Chapter 39: Small Victories

The end!? And if by friends he means the rest of the Fellowship, I think they will understand...even the hobbits, if not Boromir. Galadriel if she hears though, what will she think?...especially since it wasn't Gimli. Now what will Thranduil think? I must read on.

PSW · 30 September 2021 · Chapter 39: Small Victories

Beautiful, hopeful, and sad — which is of course appropriate for Middle Earth, where there is no beauty, joy, or triumph without sadness. A lovely read, thx for sharing!

PSW · 28 September 2021 · Chapter 11: Farewell, Fare Free

I remembered liking this story, and I am enjoying it again. I just love your take on Legolas.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 39: Small Victories

I really enjoy reading this story. Great character development, well written descriptive storyline. I often read late at nights but it was absolutely worth it. It would be wonderful if you could consider to write more what happened to Legolas and Gimli later and I really would love to read about reunion in Valinor. Thank you so much for your story.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 38: A King's Ransom

Can't believe that Legolas did it.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 37: The Thunder Rolls

Thorin is a great king. Action and characters so well written I can picture them easily like a movie.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 36: Three Steps Back

Your story keeps getting better and better. There is never a dull moment in the whole series.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 35: In Kindred Fire

You are having a hypnotic way of story telling. Amazing cliffhanger.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 34: Two Steps Forward

Incredible action packed story.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 33: Across the Threshold

Kali is a great character. I was sitting again till 1 p.m but o could not put your story down.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 32: Shades of the Elvenking

Thorin seems to be friendly. Love your story.

mystarlight · 20 December 2019 · Chapter 31: As the River Runs

I am so happy Dorthaer survived!!!

mystarlight · 19 December 2019 · Chapter 30: Down the Swift Dark Stream

Want to hug Thranduil now. It is so brave of Legolas to go with Gimli at once and not wait for news.

mystarlight · 19 December 2019 · Chapter 29: Gold and Crimson

Thranduil let him go!!! Another sleepless night but this is much more important :D

mystarlight · 19 December 2019 · Chapter 28: What Would You Have Me Do?

Awesome council meeting!!!

mystarlight · 19 December 2019 · Chapter 27: Burnt Bridges Rebuilt

Thranduil made his mind about Gimli but it had to be a difficult decision. Wonderful development of characters and plot.

mystarlight · 19 December 2019 · Chapter 26: What Must Be

At last this difficult conversation is over. LOVE LOVE LOVE this portrayal of Thranduil.

mystarlight · 19 December 2019 · Chapter 25: Wine and Inquisition

Thranduil having a fun is a rare sight. Love the atmosphere of this festival.

mystarlight · 19 December 2019 · Chapter 24: The Demands of Honor

Love it!!! Poor Gimli everything he believed about Thranduil was a bit different. It had to be a shock but I admire his flexibility.

mystarlight · 18 December 2019 · Chapter 23: Reservations

Gimli is for Thranduil like a sort of inappropriate friend Legolas could have in a teenage rebellion :).

mystarlight · 18 December 2019 · Chapter 22: Thorns Amid Roses

'Thranduil struck with coiled serpentine precision, the effect leaving his victim somewhat stunned', 'This Elf would not fell you with mythical powers or magic rings; rather he would strap you outright with his own two hands'. You left me speechless again!!! I can't thank you enough for sharing your wonderful story!!!

mystarlight · 17 December 2019 · Chapter 21: That Which Endures

Thranduil fighting with the one of nine had to be a sight!!! Did he fight with his winged beast too? Had to remind myself to breath during this chapter!!! The king scrubing his floors is absolutely amazing. Love loyalty of his family and friends but his ability to sense his son is really great and perfectly shows his bond with Legolas. Pity it wasn't you who wrote the script for the Hobbit!!! Then we would get a blockbuster.

mystarlight · 17 December 2019 · Chapter 20: And Unto Dust You Shall Return

This chapter made me cry.

mystarlight · 17 December 2019 · Chapter 19: Remember That You Are Dust

It sounds as if during the battle orcs got a special order to do everything to humiliate or harm Thranduil. I can't stop thinking why Sauron hates him so much. Is it because of his will and strength? As you said he had no special ring and only his will kept darkness at bay.