Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search
swiss replica watches replica watches uk Replica Rolex DateJust Watches

A Small and Passing Thing  by Lindelea 3 Review(s)
FnatasyFanReviewed Chapter: 11 on 10/6/2003
It's getting worrysome watching Freddy's inner torment continue. I know it's really been a short time since he was liberated, that he is very weak and that you cannot undo in a day what has been painfully learned over months; however, it's sad to watch the hobbits around him think they are making progress without realizing Freddy distinuishes very little reality amid terrible delusions. Someone will have to break the mental barriers soon, or I am afraid the healer's fears could become true.

Ooooo, Regi doesn't know Estella is there. I can't believe she's still with Rosemary's family. Is it possible she's gone to the Smials but kept her disguise for the whole time? I wouldn't put it past Estella to have tried. She seemed quite fiery and mischievious in the earlier stories. She might have done it for a lark, or she might have chosen to grasp at the relative freedom a young boy would have, compared to the cosseted youngest lass of a gentle-born hobbit family. She's got enough Took in her to look at this as an advenure of her own, and a chance to do something besides hide from the ruffians. Or is there totally something else going on? I love to try to guess, even when I'm wildly wrong.

I'll be eagerly waiting to see you pick up this cliffhanger!

HaiReviewed Chapter: 11 on 10/5/2003
Oh, no! Where is Estella if not here? Still at the Woody End? I hope the Bolgers will all be reunited soon! They have been through a lot! How wonderful of Lobelia to give back Bag End and even want to pay for it to be fixed! Looking forward to more! Thank you!

MirielReviewed Chapter: 11 on 10/5/2003
Oh no! Where could Estella be? Or is she still "twig?"

My heart just breaks as Fatty's tortured mind refuses to take the food-so sad.

Very smart of the hobbits, to make themselves look far poorer than they are.

This is excellent. Update soon!

Return to Chapter List